PROVISION OF SERVICES REGULATIONS

The ASSC has highlighted a potential illegality of the draft short-term let licensing legislation, under the Provision of Services Regulations, preserved in UK law by the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.

The ASSC engaged the respected legal firm Burness Paull LLP in Summer 2021 to provide expert comment on the Scottish Government’s short-term let regulatory plans and their arguments are set out from points below (16-19) in this submission.

In our view, the proposed licensing regimes are incompatible with the legal requirements of the Provision of Services Regulations (the “Regulations) 2009 (as amended) and the Provision of Services (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2018 which preserved the Regulations notwithstanding the UK’s withdrawal from the EU.

The Regulations protect UK businesses and consumer rights by maintaining obligations on UK competent authorities to ensure that their regulation of service activity is proportionate and justified in the public interest. Service activity includes tourism activity which we have interpreted as encompassing self-catering accommodation provision.

Overriding reasons of general interest relevant to short-term accommodation rental services can be: social policy objectives such as ensuring the availability and affordability of local housing; the protection of the urban environment; public security; the protection of consumers; and ensuring tax compliance and effective fiscal supervision.

Justifications for imposing policy and regulatory restrictions on short-term accommodation rental services must be supported by clear evidence that the general interest needs to be protected, and evidence of the link between short-term accommodation rental services and the protection of the general interest.

The Scottish Government has provided no empirical data that there is a direct link between short-term letting and loss of housing stock, thus it cannot be considered to be an overriding reason of general interest.

The Regulations require that an authorisation (licensing) scheme can only be implemented under certain circumstances: to treat issues locally, if these issues are justified by an overriding reason of general interest. In these circumstances, a registration/authorisation (licensing) scheme must be simple, fast, easy to complete, the criteria should be clear, objective and transparent. Once again, we have serious concerns that the draft Order does not meet these requirements.

REQUIREMENTS OF THE REGULATIONS

  • Specific requirements of the Regulations which we consider the draft Order to breach include:
  • Part 3 of the Regulations Competent authorities are required to provide a clear process for their authorisation scheme and that any scheme meets the requirements within the Regulations. Businesses cannot be prohibited from delivering a services activity due to an economic test, involvement of competing operators or other requirements such as quantitative or territorial restrictions, minimum number of employees etc.
  • Competent authorities are obliged not to impose disproportionate or unnecessary requirements on businesses that seek to provide services, unless justified. We have queried above the failure of the Scottish Government to date to provide a sound, evidence-based justification for its approach.
  • Conditions for the granting of authorisation: An authorisation scheme must be based on criteria which preclude any competent authority from exercising its power of assessment in an arbitrary manner.
  • The criteria must be: (a) justified by an overriding reason relating to the public interest (ORRPI); (b) proportionate to that public interest objective; (c) clear and unambiguous; (d) objective; (e) made public in advance; and(f) transparent and accessible.
  • We have set out above our views that the Scottish Government has failed to provide empirical data to support the proposition that these requirements are necessary and justified in the public interest or that they are objective or proportionate.

FEES

  • Fees charged by a competent authority under an authorisation scheme must be reasonable and proportionate to the cost of the procedures and formalities under the scheme, and must not exceed the cost of those procedures and formalities. See regulation 18(4) of the Regulations.
  • Fees should not be used as an economic deterrent to certain activities or to raise funds. If a business believes the fee to be disproportionate, they can contest it with the competent authority concerned.
  • We have set out above why we consider that the fees approach proposed is excessive, disproportionate and constitutes a real deterrent to many small businesses in raising funds or simply continuing to operate.

Edinburgh Council Launch Short-Term Let Control Area Consultation

City of Edinburgh Council have today launched their consultation into designating the entire city as a Short-Term Let Control Area.

Under these plans, “a property owner who is letting out a residential property (which is not their principal home) on a short-term let basis would have to apply for ‘change of use’ approval through the planning application process”. It will not affect those who engage in ‘homesharing’ – that is, “the letting rooms or letting out the whole residential property where it is the owner’s principal home and the owner is absent.”

The consultation, which was approved by the Planning Committee, will run for nine weeks until 5th November 2021. The ASSC will provide a full briefing to members in due course but information from the Council relating to the consultation and how to respond can be accessed here: https://consultationhub.edinburgh.gov.uk/sfc/short-term-let-consultation/

Responses to the Council will be used to inform the decision on taking forward a Short-Term Let Control Area for formal designation – Scottish Government Ministers will ultimately be responsible for approving Edinburgh’s plans.

The ASSC believes that City of Edinburgh Council’s Short-Term Let Control Area proposals are disproportionate, lack a robust evidence base and will damage Edinburgh’s renowned tourist economy.

For some facts and data on short-term letting in Edinburgh, read more: Edinburgh Briefing – ASSC

We have issued the following comment to media in response to the announcement:

Fiona Campbell, Chief Executive Officer of the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers, said:

“Edinburgh Council’s draft proposals for a short-term let control area covering the entire city are wholly disproportionate and lack an empirical evidence base to substantiate claims that such accommodation has reduced housing stock.”

“Furthermore, their proposals appear to rely on pre-pandemic listings from one online platform only and this does not provide an accurate reflection of the situation.”

“Self-catering properties have been a longstanding presence in the capital for decades, enhancing the tourist offering and boosting the local economy, and should not be used as a convenient scapegoat for policy failures elsewhere. Communities are being hoodwinked into believing that regulating short-term lets out of existence will act as a panacea when in reality, we have failed to build enough affordable homes or bring large numbers of empty properties back into use.”

“Self-catering generates £70m for Edinburgh’s economy. For a city that is renowned for its hospitality, it is very disappointing that local policymakers are looking to solve multifaceted housing challenges in Edinburgh by concentrating on tourist accommodation and damaging small businesses in the process.”

“The ASSC looks forward to supplying evidence to the consultation and highlighting the need for balanced, targeted and proportionate regulation for the benefit of all concerned stakeholders in the city.”

Scotland’s Economy: An update on Covid baseline measures for business

“Ms Forbes, The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy has just issued this statement online, highlighting the need for everyone to remain focused on current baseline measures and their importance to the collective effort to supress the virus.

“The guidance that remains in place around baseline measures and good practice is highlighted here:

Coronavirus (COVID-19): tourism and hospitality sector – gov.scot (www.gov.scot)

“As you will all be aware, we remain in a delicate place with high rates of infection across the country, so we need to collectively focus on maximising adherence on current baseline measures.”

Since the start of the pandemic, businesses have made huge changes and sacrifices to protect public health. I’m incredibly grateful to the business community and would like to thank everyone who has spent time and effort to make their businesses as safe as possible for customers and staff. Your contribution has been vital in helping us control the spread of the virus.

We know these necessary modifications have often had a detrimental impact on the economic activity of businesses so I’m pleased our economy is now able to open fully as we move beyond Level 0.

However, the virus has not disappeared and case numbers have been increasing. That is why it is important we keep some precautionary measures in place to allow for a gradual and cautious approach, particularly as we move into the winter when more people will be interacting indoors. This will help to reduce the risk of outbreaks and allow all sectors of the economy to stay open.

Businesses have shown great leadership throughout the pandemic in encouraging adherence with mitigations and we would ask that this continues at this fragile time. I would urge customers to follow the guidance too, to support the businesses they use.

The most important step we can take to control the virus is to get vaccinated and we would encourage all who have not yet been vaccinated to do so.

Alongside this we urge businesses to continue to communicate and work with their employees to implement measures which will help us supress the virus:

  1. wear face coverings – this is legally required in most indoor public places including retail, restaurants, cafes, bars, workplaces and on public transport for staff and customers
  2. support staff to self-isolate if they are asked to do so by the NHS
  3. regular testing of staff to help break the chains of transmission
  4.  support staff to work from home some of the time to reduce the ability of the virus to transmit
  5. keep your premises as well ventilated as possible

Guidance for safer businesses and workplaces can be found on the Scottish Government website, including a range of further precautionary measures and good practice which can be used in workplaces to reduce the risk of outbreaks.

By working together, we can ensure businesses remain open and our economy recovers from the effects of the pandemic.

Kate Forbes
Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy

During her COVID-19 media briefing today, First Minister Nicola Sturgeon covered the follow (27/08/21):

  • The FM reported that 6,835 new cases of COVID-19 had been registered and that 479 people were in hospital, with 47 in intensive care. She also reported that there had been 4 additional deaths, bringing the total to 8,103. On vaccines, she noted that 4,085,552 people had received their first dose of the vaccine and 3,587,145 second doses had been administered.
  • The FM noted that this was the sharpest rise in new cases since the pandemic began and that it was a cause for concern. However, she also observed that there had been a record number of tests and that vaccines were having a positive effect. However, she reiterated her claim that the situation was “fragile”.
  • The FM confirmed that she was not considering a “circuit breaker lockdown” at the moment.
  • The FM reiterated her calls for businesses and individuals to observe the guidance in place but noted that she could not rule out further measures in future.
  • In the following session of questions, STV asked what the tipping point for further rules being imposed would be. The FM responded by saying that it was not a binary decision and that the government was monitoring the situation closely. ITV Border raised the case of the South of Scotland, which had seen people turned away at hospitals. The FM said that she was aware of the situation and encouraged everyone in the area to do what they could to alleviate the pressure on local services. The Herald and the Mail both raised the subject of vaccine passports. The FM noted that there were ethical concerns to be considered but that the Scottish Government wouldn’t rule any further action.