Highland Council Publishes Concerns about STL Legislation

Highland Council have released a statement on the draft Short-Term Let Legislation:

A response to the Scottish Government from The Highland Council seeks clarification on the Government’s proposals for licensing of short term lets.

Highland Councillors are to discuss the local authority’s response to the Scottish Government’s Short Term Lets consultation on draft Licensing Order and Business and Regulatory Impact Assessment (BRIA) tomorrow, 31 August 2021, at the meeting of the Communities and Place Committee.

Short term lets can bring substantial economic benefits to communities but they can also have negative aspects in reducing availability of residential housing and in some circumstances, disturbing residents.

The Council has engaged on the issues around Short Term Lets with the Scottish Government since it set up its panel on the collaborative economy in 2017. The Council responded to the Government in August 2019; September 2020; to the Scottish Parliament on their call for views in January 2021 and again to the Scottish Government on the Licensing Control Order by the deadline of 13 August 2021.

The Government have published legislation on introducing Control areas to manage high concentrations of secondary letting in areas where it can affect availability of residential housing. The Council are aware of the pressures in areas of the Highlands due to short term lets and are considering options for a framework policy on Control areas.

The recent consultation was on the proposed licensing  of short term lets and it outlines changes the Government have made to the proposed Licensing Order following the previous consultation include: bothies; excluded tenancies; temporary exemptions; overprovision; public register; energy efficiency and energy performance certificates; insurance; and the definition of ‘short-term letting activity’.

Key matters raised in the response were officers’ concerns regarding the ‘overprovision’ rationale and the timescale for gathering evidence for an Overprovision Policy Statement by October 2022. Clarification has been requested as this will require Highland Council to carry out site visits and monitor compliance and enforcement on around 10,000 premises in the region.

The new regulations will have significant resource implications for the Council in terms of Planning, Licensing and Environmental Health. When the Licensing Order is brought into force the Council will have a duty to establish a licensing scheme for short-term lets in the area.

See the news release.

The Communities and Place Committee highlight two main concerns:

  • officers are concerned that the introduction of overprovision is confusing as the purpose would appear very similar to Control Areas.
  • officers are concerned over the timescale for gathering evidence for an Overprovision Policy Statement by October 2022.

Read the Committee Notes.

 

BETTER REGULATION AGENDA AND THE REGULATOR’S STRATEGIC CODE OF PRACTICE

The ASSC engaged the respected legal firm Burness Paull LLP in Summer 2021 to provide expert comment on the Scottish Government’s short-term let regulatory plans and their arguments are set out below.

We consider that the draft Order creates a regulatory framework that is manifestly inconsistent with the Scottish Government’s Better Regulation Agenda [18] and the principles of regulation being proportionate; consistent; accountable; transparent and targeted only where needed

Furthermore the draft Order creates a framework that is inconsistent with the Regulator’s Strategic Code of Practice to which local authorities as regulators must have regard under Section 5 (5) of the Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Act 2014 in exercising any regulatory functions.

In particular we consider that the draft Order would effect breaches of the Code in the following manner:

Clause 2 of the Code: Regulators should pursue a positive enabling approach in their pursuit of outcomes, which contribute to ‘sustainable economic growth’. [Section 4 and 5, Paper 2: Draft Licensing Order] demonstrate the drastic economic consequences that will inevitably result from the new regulatory proposal.

Clause 2 of the Code. Regulators require to be committed in their decisions, actions and policies to the five principles of better regulation: regulation should be transparent, accountable, consistent, proportionate and targeted only where needed. However, as has been outlined above, the ASSC considers the entire framework to be disproportionate, potentially inconsistent in its application between regulators (e.g., local authorities) and that, without empirical data, seeks to regulate distinct sections of the self-catering industry in a blunt and blanket manner manifestly failing to target its regulation at genuine, identified issues.

Clause 3 of the Code requires Regulators to be enablers to help support businesses to grow sustainably. The draft Order for all of the aforementioned reasons cannot meet this objective it will stifle rather than support small businesses in this sector. This regulatory framework would also force regulatory decisions to be taken in a manner that is entirely inconsistent with many of the principles in this clause including:

  • minimising business compliance costs, where possible, by reducing unnecessary bureaucracy and delays;
  • helping those they regulate to design simple and cost-effective compliance solutions to improve confidence and day to day management control.

POTENTIAL HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATION

POTENTIAL HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATION

The ASSC has identified a potential human rights violation: Protocol 1, Article 1 and Article 17 of the Charter on Fundamental Rights – Right to Property.

The ASSC engaged the respected legal firm Burness Paull LLP in Summer 2021 to provide expert comment on the Scottish Government’s short-term let regulatory plans and their arguments are set out below.

We seriously question whether the draft Order is compliant with the European Convention on Human Rights (“ECHR”).  Protocol 1 Article 1 provides that every natural or legal person is entitled to peaceful enjoyment of their possessions.  To be deemed compatible with Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, the interference must fulfil certain criteria: it must comply with the principle of lawfulness and pursue a legitimate aim by means reasonably proportionate to the aim sought to be realised.   It is in our opinion clear that the draft Order fails to comply with the latter.

The specific public interest objective being pursued by the Scottish Government via this Order is unclear and as already articulated above, not sufficiently explained or underpinned by clear, sound data or evidence.  There appears to be no account taken of the following:

the existing regulatory framework for short-term lets.  There is no substantive evidence put forward to support the proposition that this existing framework is not fit for purpose or that the proposed measures are necessary and capable of effectively addressing potential issues such as availability of affordable housing and safety of short-term lets.  This results in the draft Order failing to be in the general interest; and

the lack of data to support the draft Order further underlines it ought to be regarded as irrational and arbitrary, such as in the case of R (Kensall) v Secretary of State for Environment [2003] EWHC Admin 459, where measures were found to be in convention of ECHR rights.

The proposed framework includes several aspects which prima facie look to be subjective and could lead to irrational decisions and/or disproportionate interference with property rights:

the short time duration of licenses, being three years, means that interference with peaceful enjoyment is extremely frequent and imposes an excessive burden, as in Sporrong and Lönnroth v Sweden [1983] 5 EHRR 35 where measures were found to be in contravention of the right to peaceful enjoyment of property;

the framework would appear to levy excessive, irregular and currently unquantifiable costs upon licence-holders and applicants; and

there are more proportionate and less intrusive measures available to the Scottish Government, including a mandatory registration scheme, as proposed by the ASSC previously.

We also challenge whether the draft Order would be in compliance with the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (the “Charter”).  Whilst the Charter no longer has effect in UK law following Brexit, the Scottish Government has made clear its desire to stay aligned with EU law as far as possible, and protect rights that existed for UK citizens.

Article 17 of the Charter provides that everyone has the right to own, use, dispose of and bequeath his or her lawfully acquired possessions, and the use of property may be regulated by law in so far as is necessary for the general interest.  For the reasons outlined above, we do not consider that objectively, a case has been made, backed up by evidence that the draft Order is either in the general interest or is only interfering in use of property so far as necessary.