Press Release: Self-Caterers Call on Committee to Reject Regulations

Scotland’s self-caterers have urged a Holyrood committee to reject damaging regulations that could cripple the sector and jeopardise the recovery of Scottish tourism.

The Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers (ASSC), which represents a vital plank of Scottish tourism, called on the Local Government Committee not to back the Scottish Government’s proposals.

The ASSC provided substantial written evidence to the committee highlighting the danger of the plans.

The committee also received an unprecedented number of submissions from people, including from hundreds of worried self-catering and B&B owners, whose businesses have been severely affected by the pandemic.

Scotland’s self-caterers have lost over £230million since September 2020 alone due to COVID-19 and the cost of additional licensing may well inflict a fatal blow on the sector, with nearly 50 percent stating that they would leave the sector as a result.

Disappointingly, the government has so far ignored calls to postpone the regulations, including a letter signed by the ASSC alongside the Scottish Tourism Alliance, the FSB, CBI Scotland, and Scottish Land & Estates.

The government also dismissed alternatives from the ASSC for a proportionate and evidence-based registration scheme for short-term lets.

Instead of listening to the industry, Scottish ministers elected to put in place a slapdash consultation, a late and inadequate Business Regulatory Impact Assessment, and a range of poorly drafted statutory instruments.

This led to the inclusion of B&Bs in the regulations, much to the confusion of industry representatives who were not consulted.

If passed, the consequences of the regulations are not limited to Scottish tourism. Several local councils highlighted the administrative and financial burden of the regulations, as the Scottish Government will not provide funding for initial set-up costs, with Highland Council now calling for implementation to be delayed.

Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers Chief Executive, Fiona Campbell, said:

“Our members, each of whom represent a small business at risk, have turned out in droves to respond to the call for evidence on this issue vital to their survival. The strength of feeling among Scottish self-caterers could not be clearer; these regulations risk killing off our businesses.”

“The scope of the regulations has spiralled out of control and will unleash a myriad of unintended consequences for operators throughout the land at a time when they can least afford it.”

“We therefore implore MSPs on the Committee to back small business and the eventual recovery of Scottish tourism by rejecting these poorly drafted and ill-considered regulations.”

ENDS

ASSC SECTORAL SURVEY: THE IMPACT OF SHORT-TERM LET LICENSING ON THE B&B SECTOR IN SCOTLAND

  • The ASSC conducted a Scotland-wide sectoral survey relating to issues concerning the impact that STL licensing would have on the Bed and Breakfast accommodation sector.
  • The online survey elicited over 300 responses from Bed and Breakfast operators in Scotland.
  • The results offer valuable insights into the experiences and problems faced by Scottish Bed and Breakfast operators and the threat this licensing will have on valuable micro businesses.

Survey Overview

  • The ASSC gathered data from Bed and Breakfast Businesses to ascertain the percentage of businesses that would fall into Use Class Order 9 (residential) and fall within the scope of the regulations and gain insights into how this legislation would affect them.
  • The ASSC ran an online survey consisting of 11 questions. This was publicised via the ASSC’s social media pages on Twitter and Facebook and shared across the tourism sector in Scotland.
  • In just 48 hours, the survey generated 308 responses.
  • The full list of questions and survey results are set out below. It also includes examples of powerful testimony from individual respondents relating to their current difficulties and why this legislation is not fit for purpose, and is damaging to the bed and breakfast sector.

Summary

It is hoped that the survey results will inform The Local Government and Communities Committee regarding the impact of this Legislation on Bed and Breakfast Operators in Scotland, as well as what changes are necessary to protect livelihoods to businesses which are a key component part of Scotland’s tourism offering.

Some of the key findings include:

  • 88% of respondents have businesses in rural / semi-rural / island locations across Scotland
  • 78% of businesses have been operating over 3 years, with 20% of businesses over 15 years, one business has been operating for over 37 years
  • 76% of Bed and Breakfasts fall in UCO9 (residential) compared to 24% UCO7 (Guest House) Therefore, 76% will be required to obtain a licence
  • 39% of respondents believe that any additional licence fee would render their business unviable.
  • While, 55% of respondents believe it would have a negative impact on their business
  • Bed and Breakfast Operators in Scotland do not have positive outlook: 85% are feeling pessimistic or very pessimistic about their business over next 6 months, and 73% over the next 12 months.

Read The Survey in Full:

The Impact of STL Licensing on the B&B Sector in Scotland

 

Letter from B&B Association

David Weston, Chair of the B&B Association has written to Kate Forbes MSP today (22nd January).

Ms Forbes,

In your email yesterday to B&B owners ** and ** of ** B&B, your words might be read as implying that we had agreed with the Scottish Government’s approach as regards the licensing of “short-term lets”.  (Your colleague Kevin Stewart made a similar statement in the Scottish Parliament on Wednesday in a reply to Oliver Mundell.)

Nothing could be further from the truth, so I’m sure you will appreciate my filling in the facts to avoid anyone being misled.

As you told your constituents ** and **, we did give written responses to Scottish Government consultations in July 2019 and October 2020 (the latter a very limited consultation, as a licensing scheme had by then been decided upon).  However you omitted the significant fact that both times, we made very clear that a licensing scheme would be the WRONG way to go, and explained why.   And in October, we specifically warned of the danger of bringing in B&Bs into the definition of “short-term lets”. Again we were ignored.

Yes we have long been in favour of levelling the playing-field between B&Bs and properties on “platforms” such as Airbnb – and we have made very clear to the Scottish Government (since 2017 when we gave evidence to your Expet Panel on the “Collaborative Economy”) that this “playing field” distortion was a matter of ENFORCEMENT.  To put it simply, traditional B&Bs are subject to the enforcement by regulators of health & safety rules, and properties on platforms like Airbnb are in practice not.  The way to bring the same level of enforcement to both is to bring in a no or low cost accommodation registration scheme, not an onerous, costly, inflexible and unwieldy licensing scheme.

So the current damaging and misconveived proposals are the result of your Government ignoring all that we said, and doing the opposite.  Which of course, is perfectly within your right to do.  But in which case, please in future make it clear that we have advised against your present course at every opportunity – and you could then explain why you feel the Scottish B&B Association is wrong and our views should be ignored.

In any case, seeking written submissions from voluntary trade associations is not sufficient as a consultation excercise before changes of this scope and scale – if your Government had intended every owner of a house (ie UCO 9) in Scotland who offered even one room as B&B to be subject to a licensing regime, it would have been incumbent on you to carry out a near population-level consultation and communications excercise.

(Whether the consultation excercise was legally watertight is, I understand, a question worth asking. Unlike Acts of the UK parliament which (generally since leaving the EU) cannot be challenged in the courts, Scottish Acts can be challenged in the Scottish Courts if they are outwith the scope of the legal powers devolved to the Scottish Parliament. But there are much wider grounds for challenging subordinate legislation (ie legislation like this Order made not by Parliament but by Ministers in exercise of powers given to them under an Act of either Parliament). These include procedural impropriety etc. which may be wide enough to include failure to properly consult key sectors affected, particularly in the context of published “best practice”. This is something we are looking into at present.)

In addition of course, if the Scottish Government had intended the scope to be that wide, a serious economic impact assessment of appropriate scope would have been needed – and again, that wasn’t done.

Many of your colleagues are surprised that B&Bs are now included within the definition of “short term lets”.  None of them to my knowledge has said that the problems giving rise to this legislation were caused by established traditional B&Bs across Scotland.  B&Bs are NOT part of the problem your SSI on Short Term Lets purports to solve – yet they will (if it is enacted as proposed) be amongst the most significant and numerous casualties.  B&Bs will suffer disproportionate new burdens and costs which are entirely unnecessary, unless this badly drafted and wrongly targeted legislation can be set aside and reviewed.

The fact that small B&Bs are covered by your draft legislation is only because our warnings on the definition of “short term lets” were ignored.

So I would be grateful if in future correspondence on this matter, if and when you or your colleagues choose to mention the Scottish B&B Association having been consulted, you make clear that we were strongly opposed to the present legislation, and explain why you have nevertheless decided to ignore our views and warnings.

Regards,

David Weston

Chairman