Request for the Withdrawal of the Scottish Government’s Short-Term Let SSIs

Back in October 2020, 38 leading tourism and business stakeholders, including many signatories to this letter, wrote to the Scottish Government to express concerns over the timing and impact of the short-term let regulations. The sector remains resolute in its belief that the proposed regulations will entail damaging consequences for Scottish tourism at a time when the sector can least afford it.

However, as developments have unfolded, this coalition of support has broadened to include other organisations, including the Scottish B&B Association and the National Farmers Union of Scotland. Moreover, it is notable that one of the most influential proponents of regulation, Andy Wightman MSP, voiced concern about what has been set out in the SSIs and argued that they should be withdrawn; while other MSPs have highlighted concerns over the scope and cost to operators, the tourist economy and local government.

Overall, it is our firm belief that:

  • The regulations are ill-timed and inopportune during the pandemic. Many businesses captured by the regulations are focused on their very survival. Numerous Covid-19 restrictions have been placed upon them and uncertainty endures as to when these might be lifted. The prioritisation of the regulations makes even less sense when similar legislation, such as the Transient Visitor Levy, has been rightfully postponed.
  • The regulations are a blunt tool to fix a perceived and localised problem of amateur operators in urban areas like Edinburgh, rather than being a solution that is appropriate for the whole of the Scotland. The regulations offer no real flexibility to local authorities where concerns over short-term lets are not an issue. The regulations will hit rural Scotland hard, with many businesses and communities depending on the economic footfall generated by visitors to self-catering accommodation.
  • The regulations go beyond what was originally envisaged as B&Bs will be captured by the licensing regime. The Scottish Government’s Short-Term Let Delivery Group did not consult with the B&B sector which we believe would be a basic duty given the impact of the regulations.
  • The regulations will be burdensome financially and from a resourcing perspective for local councils. They are already under considerable pressure due to the pandemic and, despite assurances from government that the scheme will be cost neutral, they will not receive any additional funds to assist with start-up costs. Several authorities noted these issues in their consultation responses and Highland Council has called for the implementation of the regulations to be delayed.

Unfortunately, despite such concerns, the Licensing Order was approved by the Scottish Parliament’s Local Government and Communities Committee on 3rd February 2021 by the slimmest of margins, with MSPs noting serious flaws in the SSIs. It is expected that the SSIs will be tabled for a vote in plenary at the Scottish Parliament in the immediate future.

With so many stakeholders now highlighting deficiencies in the plans, it is incredibly disappointing that there is no opportunity to amend the regulations. Given the importance of these measures to lives and livelihoods throughout Scotland, we need to get the regulations right at the first opportunity and not rely on revisiting the rules once implemented.

We would therefore respectfully recommend that the regulations are withdrawn by the Scottish Government.

Instead, it is our sincere hope that government will work constructively with affected stakeholders in the next parliament to devise balanced, proportionate and world-leading regulations that will support the sustainable recovery of Scottish tourism.

Proceeding with regulations that are not fit for purpose will merely compound the many difficulties faced by struggling businesses the length and breadth of this country. Let’s work together to get the details right for the benefit of everyone – business, visitors and local communities.

Read in Full Here

Letter to Kevin Stewart MSP 15th February 2021

ASSC Briefing for MSPs on the Scottish Government’s Short-Term Let SSIs

8th February 2021

Background 

  • The Local Government and Communities Committee recently voted to recommend that the Scottish Government’s Short-Term Let Control Areas Regulations and Licensing Order be approved, the latter being secured by the narrowest of margins and MSPs identified serious flaws in the plans.
  • We expect MSPs to vote in plenary imminently on whether to accept/reject these SSIs which will mark the culmination of what the ASSC believes to be a rushed process, one which will hold serious negative consequences for the Scottish tourism sector.
  • Throughout the recent regulatory discussion, the ASSC highlighted concerns over the following: the truncated consultation process; the impact of Covid-19 on the sector, the lack of a Business Regulatory Impact Assessment (BRIA) to accompany the consultation; the inadequacy of the late BRIA; the lack of consideration of proportionate alternatives to licensing; and that the draft SSIs would entail unintended consequences.[1] Disappointingly, these concerns were not acted upon by government.
  • The strength of feeling on this issue was highlighted by the evidence presented to Local Government Committee. They received an unprecedented level of correspondence from individual self-caterers and B&B owners whose businesses have been severely affected by pandemic but who will now be captured by these regulations.
  • The ASSC hopes that policymakers will now reconsider these proposals, support our vital tourism industry in Scotland during these challenging times, and work together to progress viable, balanced and proportionate regulations.

Main Problems with Regulations

  • Overall, the Scottish Government’s plans are a blunt tool to fix a perceived and localised problem of amateur operators in, primarily, Edinburgh, rather than being a solution that is appropriate for the whole of the Scotland. The regulations offer no flexibility to local authorities where concerns over short-term lets are not an issue. These regulations will hit rural Scotland hard, with many related businesses and communities depending on the economic footfall generated by visitors to self-catering accommodation.
  • The scope of the regulations has now spiralled out of control as small B&Bs will be captured by the licensing regime, which we do not believe to have been the policy intention of the Scottish Government. The Scottish Government’s Short-Term Let Delivery Group did not consult with the B&B sector which we believe would be a basic duty given the impact of the regulations.
  • We are incredibly disappointed at the lack of adequate scrutiny for these regulations which will affect the lives and livelihoods of professional self-caterers throughout Scotland. We note that the Scottish Government refused the Local Government Committee’s invitation to provide it with draft instruments before laying them which could have resulted in better SSIs. 
  • Similarly, it is disappointing that there is no opportunity to amend the regulations. We ought to get the regulations right at the first opportunity and not rely on revisiting the rules once implemented as the Scottish Government propose.
  • Small business concerns have been consistently ignored. Calls for a sensible postponement to enable the tourism industry to recover from Covid-19 were disregarded, despite the fact that this would mirror the approach taken to the Transient Visitor Levy. This included a letter from October 2020, signed by 38 leading stakeholders, including the ASSC alongside the Scottish Tourism Alliance, the FSB, CBI Scotland, and Scottish Land & Estates.[2]
  • If passed, the consequences of the regulations are not limited to Scottish tourism. Several local councils highlighted the administrative and financial burden of the regulations, as the Scottish Government will not provide additional funding for initial set-up costs[3], with Highland Council now calling for implementation to be delayed.[4]

Conclusion and Recommendations

  • The traditional self-catering sector is not averse to regulation and have been at the forefront of presenting comprehensive and robust set of policy recommendations that have been shared with government.[5]
  • Since September 2020 alone, Frontline Consultants estimated that the Scottish self-catering sector lost over £265M due to Covid-19 restrictions[6] and these SSIs have the potential to merely compound these difficulties.
  • As shown by our survey, nearly half (49%) of operators would leave the self-catering sector if the proposed licensing scheme was introduced.[7] This will be devastating for Scottish tourism at a time when we should be supporting business for a sustainable recovery.
  • It is our preference that the Scottish Government would move to withdraw the Regulations so that better ones could be laid in the next parliamentary session.
  • We implore you to vote against the SSIs and work with us to devise world-leading regulations that work for all – small business, tourism and local communities.

FIONA CAMPBELL, CEO, ASSOCIATION OF SCOTLAND’S SELF-CATERERS

8TH FEBRUARY 2021

 

[1] A copy of the ASSC’s written evidence to the Local Government and Communities Committee can be accessed here: https://www.assc.co.uk/policy/stl-licensing-assc-submission-to-local-government-communities-committee/

[2] https://www.assc.co.uk/industry-letter-to-government-tourism-sector-urges-regulations-rethink/

[3] https://www.parliament.scot/parliamentarybusiness/28877.aspx?SearchType=Advance&ReferenceNumbers=S5W-34589&ResultsPerPage=10

[4] https://www.parliament.scot/S5_Local_Gov/General%20Documents/STL169HighlandCouncil.pdf

[5] https://www.assc.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/2020_ForwardTogether.pdf

[6] https://www.assc.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/ASSC-Sectoral-Survey-on-Impact-of-Covid-19-Restrictions-December-2020.pdf

[7] https://www.assc.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/ASSC-licensing-survey.pdf Appendix 5

“The Booking Problem”

Why the licensing provisions of The Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 (Licensing of Short-term Lets) Order 2021 (the ‘Order”) will seriously damage the Scottish Tourist Industry, and local economies, through closure of self-catering businesses.

1          OVERVIEW

Councils have 12 months to grant or a refuse an initial licence, and 6 months for a licence renewal. Given the resource implications and other pressures on Councils, holiday let operators will assume that Council’s will need most of that time. For busy times, many guests book up to 12 months in advance. So there will be significant extended periods (shown visually in a diagram below) when operators will not be able to guarantee the booked property will be available.  Bookings will have to be conditional as there is a very real risk that a licence might be refused.

But the commercial reality is that guests will simply not book if their bookings are conditional and subject to a term between owner and guest that says the owner can cancel the booking if they cannot either obtain or renew a licence. Why would they? Many will simply vote with their feet: booking accommodation in the North of England where no such conditions will apply.

The Scottish Government don’t seem to think this is  a problem: Kevin Stewart MSP, Minster for Local Government, Housing and Planning, outlined in a letter of 11 Dec 2020 letter to Willie Rennie MSP: “With regard to the handling of bookings, please see paragraph 7.15 of the consultation report. We would expect the position in respect of refunds etc. for future bookings affected by refusal, suspension or revocation of a licence to be covered by booking terms and conditions in the same way as any other scenario in which the accommodation becomes unexpectedly unavailable, such as through fire damage or flood”.

This is equivalent to a supermarket saying to a customer: “you can put all your shopping in the basket, but we might decide we are not going to be able to sell it to you when you reach the check-out”.

This shows a complete lack of practical understanding of commercial contracts in the tourism sector and will be one of the key reasons why many owners will simply close.

2          INTRODUCTION

In a response to an October 2020 survey of property owners by the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers (ASSC), of the 1184 respondents nearly half (49%) would leave the self-catering sector if the proposed licensing scheme was introduced and of those 33% would leave the property empty or use it for family & friends[1].

The self-catering industry is the backbone of the Scottish Tourism Industry. It goes without saying how damaging business closures will be to tourism in Scotland, its supply chain and the local businesses that only tourism makes viable. And this, at a time when the Scottish Government should be encouraging staycations both to help with post-Covid economic recovery and to help minimise climate change.

There are many reasons, particularly in the context of small single property businesses which the majority are, why businesses will close: concerns with the bureaucracy involved in applying, licence conditions which may be impractical or unworkable and unknown, open ended application costs, uncertainty over recouping investment in the property (repairs, new boilers etc).

This note explains a further and very specific key concern that will further fuel business closures: the damage and uncertainty around future bookings that the licensing procedure itself creates.  

3          BASIC LICENSING REQUIREMENTS (ARTICLES 3,4 & 5)

Under article 3 of the Order as read with article 4 “short-term lets” (defined in article 2(2)) after 1 April 2022 require a licence under Part 1 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982, as amended by Schedule 2 of the Order (and also the further amendments in article 6 where the transitional provisions apply).

A licence is to be subject to the conditions in schedule 3 to the Order and to other conditions the Council may impose.

Period of licence

This is provided for by Par 8 of Sch 1 to the 1982 Act as amended by Para 7 of Sch 1 to the Order. This gives complete flexibility to the Council to decide the period before renewal is required –

  • 3 years (the default)
  • “such SHORTER period as the licensing authority may decide” (NOT disapplied by the Order)
  • “such longer period as the licensing authority may decide” (introduced by the Order)

4          TRANSITIONAL PROVISION FOR EXISTING OPERATORS (ARTICLE 6)

Article 6 provides that a person who provides a short-term let without a licence after I April 2022 does NOT commit an offence if –

  • they carried on the business before 1 April 2022, and
  • they apply for a licence before 1 April 2023, and
  • the licence application has not been determined (this includes determination an appeal made to a sheriff within 28 days of a licence refusal – see para 18(4) of sch 1 to the 1982 Act)

Article 6(2) requires the Council to reach a final decision with 12 months of the application. This does not appear to apply to licence renewal: so assumption is that 6 month limit applies for renewals.

5          THE PROBLEM

When an owner applies for a licence (or a renewal) they will not know –

  • if it will be granted or refused
  • how long the application will take

Refusal is a real not theoretical risk – explored below.

So that means that for a significant period before, and after, the date of the licence application either –

  • Future bookings will need to be conditional on a licence being obtained, failing which the owner can cancel without penalty
  • Owners will have to take the risk of cancellation

Owners taking the risk would be quite unacceptable: it would be dishonest, it would lead to potential legal claims for breach of contract and would do serious reputational damage to the Scottish tourist industry.

That leaves making bookings conditional on a licence being granted. This is the solution suggested by the Scottish Government –

“With regard to the handling of bookings, please see paragraph 7.15 of the consultation report. We would expect the position in respect of refunds etc. for future bookings affected by refusal, suspension or revocation of a licence to be covered by booking terms and conditions in the same way as any other scenario in which the accommodation becomes unexpectedly unavailable, such as through fire damage or flood.”  Kevin Stewart MSP, Minster for Local Government, Housing and Planning. 11 Dec 2020 letter to Willie Rennie MSP

This is contractually perfectly possible but commercially totally impractical and unfortunately betrays the lack of practical understanding by the team working on the Order of the way in which the self-catering industry operates in the real world. Fire damage and flood are statistically very unlikely and are risks potential guest are well aware of. Why would anyone book a holiday at a key time of year that the owner can cancel without penalty, leaving them potentially too late to find an alternative, if they don’t get a licence? How can potential guest be in a position to take view on untested risk that the business owner can’t even quantify? Much easier surely to cross the border in nearby Northumberland and the Lake District where no such conditions apply.

Worked Example

[2]

If an initial licence application is made in March 2023 (the prudent time to apply given that licence granting is not automatic and owners will wish to minimise their losses by running their, Covid damaged, businesses as long as they can), this period of uncertainty could last until March 2024. The reality is many guests book up to 12 months in advance, especially for the summer, Christmas and Easter. That means that bookings would for post 1 April 2023 bookings would start from summer 2022, and would all have to be legally conditional on a licence being granted. This uncertainty could continue until March 2024 by which time many bookings would normally be made for summer 2024 and even Christmas/New Year 2024/5. So, for a period of up to, potentially, 20 months from summer 2022 the owner would be have to make some bookings (those made before March 2023 but for post 1 April stays), then eventually all bookings (post 1 April) conditional on a licence being granted. Unless (highly unlikely) the licence is granted within a couple of months this would have implications for not just for one summer season but for 2 summer seasons (2023 and 2024) and potentially the next Christmas/New Year.

This is not a once and for all problem. Licences will be for a fixed period and then have to be renewed (see above), albeit the maximum period of uncertainty is reduced by 6 months as the local authority will have to decide within 6 months of the application submission date, not 12 months as in the case of the initial application.

6          RISK OF REFUSAL

This is a very real risk, as there are many reasons a licence could be refused:

  • Breach of planning control (1982 Act amended by Para 5 of Sch 2 of the Order)
  • Applicant would not be able to “secure compliance” with conditions (1982 Act amended by Para 6(b) of Sch 2 of the Order). That includes standard conditions the local authority may choose to apply to licences
  • The Council “considers” there will be a resulting over provision of short-term lets (1982 Act amended by Para 6(c) of Sch 2 of the Order) –

3A) A licensing authority may refuse an application for a licence for secondary letting if it considers that there is (or, as a result of granting the licence, would be) overprovision of short-term lets, or a specific type of short-term let of the same type as that to which the application relates, in the locality in which the premises is situated. 

(3B) It is for the licensing authority to determine the localities within its area for the purpose of sub-paragraph (3A).

(3C) In considering whether there is or would be overprovision for the purposes of sub-paragraph (3A) in any locality, the licensing authority must have regard to—

(a)the number and capacity of licensed short-term lets in the locality, and 

(b)the need for housing accommodation in the locality and the extent to which short-term let accommodation is required to meet that need, and

(c)such other matters as they consider relevant.”.

It is impossible for a business owner to quantify this risk.

Additionally, a licence may be granted but with conditions attached that are unacceptable to the owner.

With thanks to ASSC Member David Nash. David is a recently retired Scottish solicitor, having split his professional career between the public and private sector, in a particular as a Scottish Office legal adviser and as a partner in Shepherd & Wedderburn and as a consultant with Pinsent Masons and DWF. Until a few years ago he was also a panel member of the Scottish Parliament’s Non-Executive Bills Unit.

[1] https://www.assc.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/ASSC-licensing-survey.pdf

[2] This diagram, which assumes a licence application is made in March 2023 and takes up to 12 months to grant or refuse, shows the effect on bookings.