The Scottish Tourism Alliance – Pre Budget Submission to Scottish Government

The following letter has ben sent to the Deputy First Minister, on behalf of tourism businesses in Scotland.

Dear Deputy First Minister,

Please find attached the Scottish Tourism Alliance (STA) pre budget submission which has been developed in consultation with the STA Board STA  Counciland our STA Destination Forum Members.

Scotland’s tourism industry is at a crossroads. Before the COVID-19 pandemic, the tourism sector contributed £4.5 billion in gross value added to Scotland’s economy, employing 229,000 people, around 9% of employment in Scotland[1]. However, its future – and many of the small businesses it supports – are at risk.

When the First Minister launched the country’s new tourism strategy, Scotland Outlook 2030, in March 2020, little did we know that the sector would experience extraordinary challenges in the face of multiple lockdowns and restrictions due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

As businesses continue to recover, we now face a new set of challenges as tourism, hospitality and retail contend with unprecedented rising costs in doing business, which include escalating energy prices, increasing costs of goods and materials, and a 40-year high in inflation. This is coupled with a cost-of-living crisis with significant impact on consumer spend, particularly within the tourism and hospitality sector.

As the overarching lead representative body for Scotland’s tourism and hospitality industry, we welcome the support that the Scottish Government continues to give the sector and your recognition that an innovative, resilient, and welcoming industry is not only of vital importance to Scotland’s economy, but also its place in the world.

To achieve our shared vision of Scotland becoming the world leader in 21st century tourism, now is a critical time to ensure that the industry can survive and recover to make this ambition a reality.

Policy, investment, and positioning are three of the six conditions for success agreed in Scotland Outlook 2030. Tourism also has a central role to play in delivering the priorities set out in Scotland’s National Strategy for Economic Transformation (NSET) and the Net Zero agenda.

Our survey at the beginning of the summer period (17th May 2022 to 8th June 2022) found that more than half of tourism businesses were still not in recovery following the COVID-19 pandemic and that this could take at least another year or more, with 23% describing their business as in survival mode and financially fragile.

At the same time, we reported that a considerable number of tourism businesses had already begun to experience a decrease in customer discretionary spending compared to the same period in 2019 (52% of respondents) and 2021 (38% of respondents).

As households look to further reduce their spending in the face of rising costs, the tourism sector is predicted to once again be one of the main casualties. We are already hearing from our members that businesses are actively considering reducing their trading hours or feel financially forced to close for the winter season.

We are gravely concerned that some businesses might never reopen again, impacting on employees and wider communities, and loss of tax revenues for government. Losing businesses now could permanently reduce Scotland’s tourism capacity, resulting in wider economic and social knock-on impacts, particularly in rural areas. The uncertainty facing these businesses is also having an uncountable toll on the mental health of their owners and staff.

Out of the 744 survey responses we received, the extension of business rates relief and greater investment in tourism promotion were listed as the two most immediate and effective policies that the Scottish Government could implement to support recovery.

We would also reiterate the need to pause new and impending regulations to take some of the burden off businesses during this turbulent and uncertain time.

We urge the Scottish Government to adopt these three policies as an immediate priority to support our tourism industry.

Thank you for your ongoing support and partnership, as we continue on the path to achieving the ambitions of Scotland Outlook 2030 and delivering economic prosperity for all Scotland’s people and places.

Yours sincerely,

Marc Crothall

Chief Executive

Scottish Tourism Alliance

Scottish Tourism Alliance SG Pre-Budget Submission – 20 Sept 2022

Scottish Local Authority Licensing Schemes: Inconsistencies

A number of local councils in Scotland have, or are soon expected to launch, consultations in regard to their proposed short-term let licensing regime.[1]

Many of the draft policy statements from councils exhibit a presumption of bad practice against the short-term let industry, from issues such as anti-social behaviour to littering, which we find incredibly disheartening and disappointing given the immense economic opportunities the sector provides to Scotland, as well as the fact that many businesses in the area have been a welcome part of the community for decades.

There has already been a wide variation in the level of estimated fees set by councils[2] perhaps going beyond the principle of cost recovery. Unfortunately, there are also examples of local councils who have not provided any estimated fees as part of their draft policy or consultations, which is causing uncertainty in the sector.

Many councils are proposing that a short-term let licencing application include a layout plan at scale 1:100 which should include a legend explaining the scale used and the symbols used. Such technical layout plans may necessitate an expensive piece of work by a contractor which will be another cost on legitimate small businesses operating without issue for decades. This will be in addition to the cost of a licence fee (currently unknown), compliance with existing regulations, the mandatory and additional conditions, not to mention other factors such as rising energy costs.

In addition, some councils intend to do much more in the way of applying additional conditions than others. While the 2022 Order grants local authorities the power to set additional conditions, many are stretching the boundaries of the legislation, and there are also instances of councils replicating the mandatory conditions or existing regulations.

Some Councils are proposing that the licence holder must ensure that the bedrooms, living room and hallway in the premises are carpeted. Applying a condition that the licence holder must ensure that bedrooms, living room and hallway are carpeted is disproportionate and is yet another cost levied on businesses. This would not be asked of a private landlord renting out a property where noise complaints had been levelled by neighbours, so short-term lets operators should not be discriminated against in this manner.

At a challenging time for small business, not only due to pandemic recovery but the impact of the cost of living crisis and in particular increased energy bills, these often unnecessary additional conditions will not only hit self-caterers in the pocket but will also burden resource-stretched councils.

We have provided examples below of a sample of local councils who may be going beyond the policy intentions of licensing, or who have proposed disproportionate costs for small businesses.

Examples

City of Edinburgh Council

  • Edinburgh’s licensing consultation provides the following two options for stakeholder comment:

4.17: Option A) Secondary letting in tenement or shared main door accommodation is considered as unsuitable and there will be a rebuttable presumption against the grant of a licence in such circumstances. Option B) There will be a rebuttable presumption against the grant of a licence for secondary letting in tenement or shared main door accommodation, unless the applicant can demonstrate they have consent from the owners of all accommodation within the stair/close in which their accommodation is located.  

  • This is ultra vires to licensing, as it pertains to a planning consideration, not a safety consideration. It is conflating planning with licensing and falls outwith the intention and scope of the legislation. This opens up the Council to likely legal challenge.
  • Additionally, Questions 4 and 5 in the Council’s licensing consultation relate to limitations on the number of nights for which a short-term let could be used in each year. Capping numbers should not form part of the current consultation relating to short-term let licensing, as this again relates to the use of the property, not the safety of the activity.[3]

Argyll and Bute Council

  • Argyll and Bute Council is proposing additional conditions in relation to bike hire, watercraft, swimming pools and ponds, and play equipment, four completely unrelated activities to the activity of short-term letting.
  • A short-term let concerns the provision of accommodation to a guest. Accommodation means any building or structure, or any part of that building or structure, that is being let out to visitors. Both mandatory and additional conditions should concern matters directly pertaining to short-term lets. Such proposed additional conditions from Argyll and Bute Council clearly do not relate to the provision of accommodation.

Angus Council

  • This Council is proposing that operators ensure that “The external garden area including any facilities located in the garden such as hot tubs, swimming pools, bars or barbeques shall not be used after 2100hrs”. Operators can ask guests not to use hot tubs, swimming pools or barbeques after a certain timeframe but cannot compel them to do so. This has been criticised by Scottish Agritourism as it will have an impact on agritourism businesses located on farms.
  • Caroline Millar, owner of The Hideaway Experience in Auchterhouse: “…it’s not relevant because we don’t have neighbours and it would have a big impact on our business…[This is] completely irrelevant to a tourism business located in 650 acres of a farm in rural Angus…We pride ourselves on offering our guests the chance for complete privacy surrounded by nature in the Angus countryside, and driving around policing their behaviour would impact significantly on the guest experience and in turn our business income.”[4]
  • Angus Council also propose that “Amplified music shall not be played in the garden area or in any part of the property such that it can be heard in the garden area at any time.” If such an additional condition was taken forward, Angus Council will need to define what amplified music means as what is ‘loud’ to one individual compared to another is relative, as well as how this will be assessed. We would raise the issue of enforceability of this and would also like to see what evidence the Council holds that this is a problem within self-catering units in of itself and compared to other types of property.

Highland Council

  • Highland Council also propose limitations on the use of hot tubs. It remains to be seen how this apparent ‘hot tub curfew’ can be enforced by Council officers. Will Councils employ someone to ensure that guests are using hot tubs at appropriate hours? This appears to be another instance of short-term let businesses being discriminated against compared to other accommodation providers or types of property.
  • The ASSC believe many of the additional conditions set out by Highland Council are wholly unnecessary. This is either due to a replication of mandatory conditions; that they do not relate to the provision of accommodation through short-term letting; or are not within the control of the individual operator.

Fife Council 

  • Fife Council (and others) are excluding Guest Houses from the requirement for a licence, despite assurances from Scottish Government that “Guest houses were listed as excluded accommodation in the original Licensing Order, as laid in December 2020. However, they were included in the draft Licensing Order that went to public consultation in June 2021. The rationale for their inclusion is set out in the 2021 consultation paper (item 1 in the table at page 12): Short term lets – draft licensing order and business and regulatory impact assessment (BRIA): consultation – gov.scot (www.gov.scot)” (Comment from David Manderson, More Homes, 23rd Feb 2022).
  • Schedule 1, 1c states that Excluded Accommodation includes “a hotel which has planning permission granted for use as a hotel”. It also excludes “hostels” in 1d. Both of the above fall under Use Class Order 7. A Guest House also falls under UCO7, but is not specifically mentioned as an exclusion (Guest Houses were specifically excluded in the previous iteration of the legislation). Fife Council are therefore interpreting it incorrectly.

Orkney Council

  • Orkney Council is asking for floor plans reflecting 2005 Act liquor licensing including premises drawings, “possibly professional prepared”, at a scale of 1:100 and a location plan at a scale of 1:1250 or 1:2500 for rural locations.
    • floor plans should show the extent of the boundary of the building and the external and internal walls of the premises;
    • the location and names of any streets surrounding the building from which guests have access to the premises;
    • the location and width of each point of access to and egress from the premises;
    • the location and width of any other escape routes from the premises;
    • the location of any equipment used for the detection or warning of fire or smoke or for fighting fires;
    • the location of any steps, stairs, elevators or lifts in the premises;
    • any accommodation intended for guests with mobility impairment;
    • the number of rooms intended for sleeping; and
    • the maximum occupancy capacity of the building (excluding children under 10 years old).
    • A floor plan may include a legend through which the matters narrated above may be sufficiently illustrated by the use of symbols on the plan.
  • This is excessive given that the Order merely requires identification of maximum occupancy and that the licence holder must ensure that the number of guests does not exceed this.
  • It is a heavy handed, onerous and burdensome approach for a small accommodation provider, which will incur considerable cost.

North Ayrshire Council

  • North Ayrshire Council has taken a pragmatic approach and intends to offer a licence for ten years at first renewal. The vast majority of council intend to offer licences for a maximum of three years. City of Edinburgh Council proposes to grant licences for secondary letting for one year only.
  • North Ayrshire Council have requested formal architectural plans and 6 copies by post!

Perth & Kinross Council

  • Perth & Kinross will be asking ‘do you have planning permission’? “If they click yes we will ask them to upload the permission.  If they click ‘no’ then a checklist will pop up and if they answer ‘yes’ to any of the questions on the checklist then they need planning permission”.
  • “planning are going to work on this next week”
  • This indicates that this Council is asking for planning as a pre-requisite to licensing. . Dumfries and Galloway are unsure what to do in this regard, and are waiting from clarification from the planning department. We will need to clarify this across Scotland and alert operators to this very significant consideration. Planning permission applications and associated fees are significant.

[1] The ASSC’s responses to these local consultations can be viewed here: https://www.assc.co.uk/consultations/

[2] For instance, in Perth and Kinross, there’s a £1,600 licence fee for 11+ secondary letting, in Argyll & Bute, they intend to charge properties accommodating 21+ eight times the basic fee, while City of Glasgow Council only intends to charge £200-450. Further detail can be found in the ASSC’s cost of living briefing.

[3] It should be remembered that overprovision powers were withdrawn from the Scottish Government’s licensing legislation in November 2021. This recognises that the government’s objective with the regulations was about ensuring health and safety across all short-term lets, not addressing housing issues.

[4] Quoted in The Courier, ‘Short-term lets rules hit agritourism’, 26/08/22.

 

How Many Licences Will you Need?

The ASSC has received clarity from the Scottish Government regarding the number of licences that will be required per business.

 This clarity is most welcome.

Accommodation located within a single premises can be covered by a single licence as set out in the Civic Government (Scotland)  Act 1982 (Licensing of Short-term Lets) Order 2022:

Designation of activity

4.—(1) The activity specified in paragraph (2) is designated as an activity for which a licence under Part 1 of the 1982 Act is required.

(2) The activity referred to in paragraph (1) is a short-term let on or after 1 October 2022.

(3) Accommodation that is on a single premises requires only one short-term let licence.

The provision applies to accommodation with shared facilities (such as yurts) or standalone accommodation, such as park lodges, provided they are all on the same premises.

Further details on the provisions within the Licensing Order are included in the policy note para’s 51 – 55, and guidance Pt.1 para 8.3:

8.3. You need a licence for each premises in which you let out accommodation. Premises means accommodation and land on one site; normally premises have their own postal address. So, for example, two neighbouring cottages are likely to be separate premises (each will require a licence), whereas 15 yurts in one field are likely to be counted as one premises (requiring one licence in total).

Where the premises (accommodation and land) are all contained on one site (the same postal address – to note this is different to the same postcode), then this would be considered a single premises requiring only 1 licence to cover all the accommodation units on the site.

Examples of where a single licence would be permissible:

Example Comment
Five purpose built self-catering cottages located on a single site All five accommodation units are on a single site, and therefore considered a single premises eligible to apply for a single licence.

 

Two cottages within a farm Provided the two cottages are all within the one site, then a single licence could be issued. If the two cottages have separate postal addresses, or are listed on Registers of Scotland as two separate sites then two individual licences will be required.

 

Bed and breakfast / home share arrangement where 2 bedrooms are let in a primary residence The 2 bedrooms are 2 separately lettable accommodation units within a single premises (one primary residence), therefore a single licence would be required.

Examples where a single licence would not be permissible:

Example Comment
Tenement block with 6 flats, all flats owned by the same owner and all let out as secondary lets. Each flat is a separate premises, as there are 6 accommodation units all on separate sites (all have their own postal address). Each flat requires a separate licence.
Two neighbouring detached houses owned by the same owner and let out as secondary lets. Each house is a separate premises, as they are located on separate sites with different postal addresses, therefore a licence would be required for each house.
A field with 10 permanent lodges at one end of a village, and another field with 5 permanent lodges at the other end of the village This arrangement constitutes two separate premises, as the lodges are located on two separate sites. A licence would be required for each premises.
Guest house / B&B / home sharing type arrangement with a separately bookable annex (secondary let) within the same site. Although located on a single site, the accommodation would require two different licence types (home sharing licence and secondary letting licence). Therefore two separate licences would be required:

  1. Home sharing for the guest house / B&B / home share primary residence;
  2. Secondary letting licence for the garden annex;