European Commission Adopts a Proposal for a Regulation of Short-Term Rental

Today (7th November), the European Commission adopted a proposal for a Regulation to enhance transparency in the field of short-term accommodation rentals. This proposal aims at creating streamlined data collection and sharing obligations for hosts and online platforms. It should replace the current different and complex rules in Member States by one clear and proportionate framework for data collection and sharing throughout the EU Single Market. The new rules should complement existing instruments, such as the Digital Services Act or the Directive on administrative cooperation in the field of taxation (DAC7), which already provide public authorities with certain tools and data.

The new proposed framework (Regulation is a directly applied EU legal act in Member States) should:

  • Harmonise registration requirements for hosts and their short-term rental properties when introduced by national authorities: Relevant authorities will have to set up an online and simple registration process for hosts. Information and documentation to be provided will have to be necessary and proportionate. Once the registration procedure is completed, hosts will receive a unique registration number that will allow them to start their activity. Public authorities will need to make short-term rental rules available on national websites, so that hosts could also benefit from clear information and requirements could be respected. According to the proposal, national and local authorities retain the power to design rules and policies on short-term rentals, to deal, for instance, with health and safety issues, urban planning, security and taxation issues. In doing so, they have to respect the principles of justification and proportionality enshrined in the EU Services Directive. The data collected on the basis of this proposal should allow public authorities to better assess the situation on the ground and make more targeted and proportionate rules. The new rules also stipulate that public authorities are responsible for setting up a registration system. Existing registration schemes, at national, regional or local level, can be maintained but will have to be in line with the requirements set out in this proposal. For instance, public authorities will have to ensure that registration is possible online and to issue a unique registration number per property.
  • Clarify rules to ensure registration numbers are displayed and checked: online platforms will have to facilitate hosts to display registration numbers on their platforms. They will also have to randomly check whether hosts register and display the correct numbers. Public authorities will be able to suspend registration numbers and ask platforms to delist non-compliant hosts.
  • Streamline data sharing between online platforms and public authorities: online platforms will have to share data about the number of rented nights and of guests with public authorities, once a month, in an automated way. Lighter reporting possibilities are foreseen for small and micro platforms. Public authorities will be able to receive this data through national ‘single digital entry points’. This shall support well-targeted policy making. Public authorities, whether at local, regional or national level, will be able to request information only relevant to them. This information will be available to them via the new national single digital entry points, where platforms will make this data available. In practice, this means that, for instance, authorities from a city will only be able to request data about their city but will not get access to the data of hosts in another city, or to the data of hosts in the surrounding regions. Public authorities receiving personal data on hosts and their activity will be duly identified and authorised to receive it in full compliance with rules on personal data protection, in particular the General Data Protection Regulation. Platforms will only share the data listed in the proposal +DAC7+DSA.
  • Lighter data sharing regime for SME platforms: As a rule, platforms will have to share data on a monthly basis automatically. However, micro and small platforms that do not reach a monthly average of 2,500 hosts will have the possibility to benefit from a lighter regime
  • Allow the reuse of data, in aggregate form: the data generated under this proposal will, in aggregate form, contribute to tourism statistics produced by Eurostat and feed into the upcoming European data space for tourism. This information will support the development of innovative, tourism-related services.

Commission noted that “Short-term rentals are developing fast in the EU, largely boosted by the platform economy. They represent about one quarter of all tourist accommodation in the EU and their number is increasing significantly across the EU. This trend was confirmed during the COVID crisis: the number of short-term rental bookings during the summers of 2020 and 2021 were above the equivalent 2018 levels. In addition, the number of bookings over the first half of 2022, has increased by 138% compared with the same period in 2021. Short-term rentals have become critical for the EU tourism ecosystem, including guests and hosts, and for many communities, creating both opportunities and challenges.“

TIMELINE (1+2 years):
The Commission’s proposal will be discussed in view of adoption by the European Parliament and the Council (EHHA notes – for a year or so).
After its adoption and entry into force, Member States will have a two-year period to establish the necessary mechanisms for data exchanges.

FOR MORE INFORMATION:
Proposal for a Regulation on data collection and sharing relating to short-term accommodation rental services
Questions & Answers
Factsheet

Thanks to the European Holiday Homes Association for this update. The ASSC are founding members of the EHHA.

Scottish Government Emergency Budget Review: Short-Term Let Licensing and Local Visitor Levy

The Scottish Government has published their Emergency Budget Review following a Statement to Parliament by the Deputy First Minister John Swinney.

The review was established back in the summer to “assess any and all opportunities to redirect additional resources to those most in need, reduce the burdens on business and stimulate the Scottish economy” and review statement had been delayed as a result of events at Westminster following the UK Government’s mini-Budget and subsequent revision of fiscal plans.

In the lead-up to the Emergency Review, the Scottish Government committed to working with the business community to address challenges around increased costs and economic disruption which included reviewing a number of regulations/requirements that were expected to start soon.

Unfortunately, our proposals to pause the introduction of short-term let licensing, in the light of the cost of living crisis, was rejected; but we encouraged Scottish Ministers to meaningfully explore if there was scope to consider how any of these regulatory impacts could be moderated to try and help reduce the burden on business.

The Emergency Budget Review states that the Scottish Government will “work with local authorities and business stakeholders to encourage, where possible, consistency in the application of short terms lets, regulations and associated fees.” The Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers will work tirelessly to keep the government to their word, just as we are to supporting our members navigate through the legislation.

In relation to another regulatory challenge, the Emergency Budget Review also states that the Scottish Government will continue to engage with businesses and other stakeholders on legislative proposals for a Local Visitor Levy (aka the tourist tax). In line with the existing parliamentary timetable and plans, these proposals will not be fully implemented until at least 2026. However, the ASSC has a number of concerns about plans for a tourist tax at the present time and will endeavour to keep our members informed of any developments.

The Statement to Parliament by the Deputy First Minister John Swinney MSP can be accessed here: https://www.gov.scot/publications/emergency-budget-review-ministerial-statement/

The outcome of the Emergency Budget Review 2022 to 2023 can be read in full here: https://www.gov.scot/publications/emergency-budget-review-2022-23/

Cost of Living Survey

Scotland’s tourism industry – of which self-catering plays an integral part – has already been through one of the most challenging times due to the impact of Covid-19 but now faces further uncertainty and economic difficulty with the cost-of-living crisis and impending licensing and planning control regulations.

  • The ASSC gathered feedback in October from nearly 1,000 short-term let operators across Scotland to determine where they are right now and what the immediate challenges relating to the cost-of-living crisis and short-term let regulations following the drastic implications of COVID.
  • The findings of this survey raise serious implications for the continued viability of many small tourism accommodation businesses in Scotland going forward, especially in rural areas, due to the perfect storm of increased regulation, changes in booking behaviour and rising costs facing self-caterers.
  • Nearly half of self-caterers are now considering closing their business over Winter 2022 for the first time due to the cost-of-living crisis, which will hugely impact Scottish tourism, while future bookings are expected to be much worse than pre-Covid.
  • A majority of businesses are still heavily concerned about the impact of short-term let licensing. The Scottish Government recently rejected proposals to delay the introduction of this despite the cost crisis and the fact that many resource-stretched local councils are not ready to establish their scheme.
  • The cumulative impact of these pressures on self-catering operators cannot be underestimated, with nearly four-in-ten reporting mental health problems as a result.
  • The ASSC sincerely hopes that policymakers take cognisance of these findings and do all they can to support small business through these challenging times.

SUMMARY

  • Nearly 1,000 (937) operators in Scotland completed the survey.
  • 41% of those surveyed are in the pre-retirement age bracket of 55-64 yrs and 76% within this age bracket are female.
  • The majority of short-term let operators tend to be located in rural areas which very often means higher living costs and additional challenges such as ferry issues.
  • Bookings for winter 2, spring 23 and summer 23 are looking much worse than pre-Covid. 54% of those surveyed say that Spring 2022 bookings are looking worse to much worse in comparison to 2019 (pre-covid).
  • The survey highlights a significant change in booking behaviour. Generally, this tends to be more last-minute bookings and less bookings overall. There are concerns that the emerging cost of living crisis will accelerate the cancellations.
  • The survey highlights that many operators (45%) are thinking of closing their business over the winter for the first time due to the cost-of-living crisis. This will impact considerably on the rural tourism economy including employment, retail, hospitality etc.
  • Additional cost of living costs will impact on businesses in a number of ways. A staggering 60% say that they will now have less to spend on fixtures, fittings and maintenance. This will impact on the overall quality of the tourism product offering in Scotland and the reputation of Scotland as a sustainable, quality destination.
  • Short-term let licensing continues to be a significant concern for the majority of businesses with over 70% concerned about the licence not being granted. Meanwhile, 87% consider the scheme to be ‘burdensome’ and 49% have considered stopping letting their property. A staggering 94% of those that might sell up say that their property would not be available for affordable housing.
  • 64% of businesses ask for clear and timely communications from the Scottish Government and local councils.
  • Following Covid, these businesses are having to navigate through STL licensing, associated costs and now the cost-of-living crisis, we asked in the survey how this is affecting their mental health. 39% of those surveyed are experiencing new mental health problems.

Read the full results: Cost of Living Survey October 2022