ASSC CEO Joins STA Call with the First Minister

STA CEO Marc Crothall and Chair Stephen Leckie had a private call with Scotland’s First Minister yesterday (11th November). Fiona Campbell, Chief Executive of the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers was invited on the call.

Nicola Sturgeon very generously afforded us considerably more than the scheduled half hour call to discuss in depth the current challenges faced by our industry. The call was scheduled for half an hour, however, the First Minister generously offered us more than 45 minutes to hear evidence on how hard the pandemic has hit the tourism sector and took time to explain the rationale behind current government policy and restrictions to curb the virus.

The conversation started on the topic of the Short Term Let Consultation; Fiona Campbell was invited to put forward views and evidence from the sector and asked that given the current uncertainty within the self-catering sector and timescale for proposed STL legislation, that the consultation is postponed, the sector is given time to recover from the impact of the pandemic and not burdened with further regulation and cost at the moment.

She highlighted the fact that the ASSC is not against regulation but that more time is required for potential legislation to be properly scrutinised and that the ASSC is committed to working with the Scottish Government to ensuring a positive outcome on the area of short term lets for Scottish tourism.

The First Minister stated that she can’t give a commitment to postponement but will commit to considering the points that the ASSC had put forward carefully in its letter of October which was co-signed by a broad range of sector and wider business organisations. She also said that the Business and Regulatory Assessment (BRIA) will be made public and that one of the purposes of the consultation is to gather views that influence the preparation of the BRIA, which will be published along with legislation.

Ms Sturgeon highlighted the fact that the Scottish Government is committed to listening carefully to the evidence presented to them and will continue to do that in this case, but will have to balance the other side of it which is looking at the purpose of the proposals in the first place.  She reiterated that she takes on board all points and that the purpose of part of the overall objective of the consultation is to have a responsible and sustainable approach to tourism recovery; however there are a number of difficult issues to balance and the Scottish Government will endeavor to do that.  She has said that a more detailed response will come in the near future.

The full conversation can be found here.

FM Statement 10th November 2020

During her statement to Parliament, the First Minister covered the following (10/11/20):

  • The FM confirmed that additional 832 new cases of COVID-19 had been identified, bringing the total to 75187. She also confirmed that 1239 people were in hospital, with 102in ICUs. She further confirmed that there had been 39 additional death reported in the previous 24 hours bringing the total to 3079.
  • Prior to outlining the revised level, the FM praised the effect that the restrictions had been having but also warned viewers not to expect many council areas to be reclassified.
  • The FM confirmed that no local authority would move to a lower tier, stating “It would not be prudent to ease restrictions today. While no local authority will move to level 4 this week, there are a number that are giving us some cause for concern and we will be monitoring these particularly closely over the next few days.”
  • Highland, Orkney, Moray, and Shetland were announced to be remaining in level 1.
  • The FM announced that, in the island authorities, people will be able to meet in one other household with a limit of six people.
  • The FM confirmed that Aberdeen City, Aberdeenshire, DNG, Borders, and Argyll and Bute would remain at level 2
  • The FM also confirmed that Angus, Fife, and Perth and Kinross would move to level 3 from Friday. “The advice of the Chief Medical Officer and National Clinical Director is that level 2 restrictions may not be sufficient to slow down and reverse increases of this magnitude and, as a result, an early move to level 3 was strongly recommended.”
  • The FM also noted that the level 3 areas were under constant review, indicating that some were close to level 4, but that no areas were to be put into level 4 at the moment.
  • On the subject of travel restrictions, she said: “Let me stress the travel restrictions that remain essential to tackling the virus. These will remain in guidance over the next week but we continue to prepare the regulations, and resolve the practical issues, that would be required to put them into law.”
  • The First Minister also reiterated the current guidance, “If you live in a level 3 council area, do not travel outside your own local authority area unless it is for essential reasons such as work that can’t be done at home, healthcare, or caring responsibilities. And if you live elsewhere, do not travel into a level 3 area, except for those same essential purposes.”
  • The Covid protection level (tier) for each of Scotland’s local authority areas and guidance on what you can and can’t do has been published on the Scottish Government website here.
  • The FM closed by reiterating the rules that are currently in place as well as the FACTS guidance.
  • In the questions session, Scottish Conservative Holyrood group leader, Ruth Davidson, quizzed the FM on her plans for the imminent Pfizer vaccine, Scottish Labour leader, Richard Leonard, pressed the FM on the restrictions and their legal enforceability, Green co-convener, Alison Johnstone talked about the UK Government, Scottish Liberal Democrat leader, Willie Rennie, clashed with the FM on student testing. Further, Both Maurice Golden and Bruce Crawford asked the FM about the support available to the tourism and hospitality sector, mentioning self-catering specifically.

 

Financial Support for the Self-Catering Sector

The ASSC sought clarification on the following subject: ‘Apart from furlough, is there any support available to businesses who are partially closed due to people not being able to stay with them anymore?’

Response from the Scottish Government:

Regarding additional support to businesses such as self-catering, which are still able to operate but have reduced custom due to restrictions on households meeting indoors and / or travel restrictions due to the tier system – eligibility for business support grants (depending on rateable value) are now targeted at businesses required to close by law or at businesses that remain open but are directly impacted by restrictions. 

 This means that:

  • Businesses are only eligible for Hardship Fund support if they are in Level 3 or 4, and the regulations require them to close or operate differently
  • Self-catering businesses, that are in Level 1&2 or Level 3, but are finding visitor numbers lower because of the travel / gatherings restrictions are not eligible for Hardship Fund support.
  • Funding eligibility is dependent on what level the business itself is in and what direct restrictions are placed on it, rather than its customer base.  Indirect restrictions, arising from both travel and socialising restrictions are not a basis for additional financial support. 

I appreciate how tough the current conditions are for you and the self-catering sector and know that this is will not be the response you’d hoped for.  However, we have noted your call for an additional financial support package, and are considering all requests within the context of the recommendations within the Tourism Recovery Taskforce report.  In the current financial climate there are a number of sectors within  tourism and hospitality which have unfortunately not yet received any targeted financial support and this is likely to be the focus for prioritising limited financial support available.  We also continue to urge the UK Government to transfer the financial powers needed to fully respond to the economic crisis caused by the pandemic.