Briefing: The Impact of Covid-19 on Scottish Self-Catering – Financial Support for Operators

The following briefing has been sent to all MSPs this afternoon.

Overview

  • Covid-19 has had a devastating impact on Scottish society and the economy. Those in the tourism sector, including self-catering, have been particularly impacted by the restrictions to combat the pandemic.
  • The cumulative impact of these measures, from limits on household gatherings to widespread travel restrictions, means that self-catering in Scotland faces a very bleak winter if no measures are taken to mitigate this.
  • A combination of a non-existent customer base coupled with no financial support from government leaves the sector in an unsustainable position, one that jeopardises the livelihoods of hardworking professionals and the economic benefit they provide to local communities.
  • The Scottish Government should therefore reconsider the eligibility criteria for their financial support for businesses hit by Covid-19 restrictions so that more self-caterers can access these vital funds.

Previous Scottish Government Financial Support

  • Earlier this year, the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers was grateful for the financial support provided by the Scottish Government through the grant scheme, although access to these funds was beset by problems concerning eligibility. To rectify this, the Scottish Government created a £1m fund for self-caterers, administered by Visit Scotland and the ASSC, that enabled redress for some of those who had missed out on vital support.
  • Moreover, in the summer, the sector was buoyed by the reopening of tourist accommodation and self-catering led the way with government backed cleaning protocols and the safe reopening from early July onwards.

Effect of Covid-19 Restrictions on Self-Catering

  • However, the accumulation of various coronavirus restrictions since that time has resulted in a deleterious situation for professional self-caterers the length and breadth of Scotland. The restrictions on gatherings to one household has rendered self-catering businesses accommodating 7+ unviable since 23rd September 2020. This accounts for a substantial proportion of the market in Scotland.
  • Furthermore, with the recent restrictions placed on travel, just under half of the Scottish population cannot travel outwith their local authority area and those travelling from the Central Belt (where most level 3 and 4 areas are located) comprise a sizeable component part of the market for rural self-catering properties.
  • Moreover, another key part of the domestic market, travellers from the rest of the UK cannot travel to Scotland at the present time.

The Lack of Financial Support for Scottish Self-Catering

  • In terms of eligibility for a temporary closure grant, self-catering is eligible at Level 4. In respect of business restriction funds, self-catering is not listed in terms of eligibility.[1] As Scottish Government guidance makes clear in respect of both funds “any business not specifically mentioned is ineligible.”[2]
  • Self-catering units outwith Level 4 are thus excluded from business restriction funds, despite the travel restrictions directly impacting bookings, as well the cumulative effect of various Covid-19 restrictions that render self-catering unviable.
  • On 26th November, the Scottish Government’s Tourism Directorate stated:

“Self-catering, B&Bs and Visitor attractions businesses that are in Level 1&2 or Level 3, but are finding visitor numbers lower because of the travel / gatherings restrictions are not eligible for Hardship Fund support.

Funding eligibility is dependent on what level the business itself is in and what direct restrictions are placed on it, rather than its customer base. Indirect restrictions, arising from both travel and socialising restrictions are not a basis for additional financial support.”

  • Self-caterers in Levels 1, 2 and 3 in Scotland are legally able to remain trading, but their business has all but disappeared – yet they have no access to funds to help them through. Alongside the lack of support from the Scottish Government, self-caterers are unable to access various schemes from the UK Government, including Furlough and Self-Employment Income Support, and cannot benefit from mortgage holidays beyond six months.
  • It is our understanding that in England, there is no similar restriction to our sector in respect of the Local Restrictions Support Grant (LRSG Open) which supports businesses that have been severely affected by local restrictions but have not closed. We believe this underlines the importance of ensuring fairness from the provision of business support grants in Scotland and ensuring each and every penny from the UK Government’s business support consequential funding is effectively utilised by the Scottish Government to protect businesses in this country. 

Recommendations

  • We are extremely concerned that we are now at a stage of irreparable damage to the self-catering sector, jeopardising the future of the £723m industry that boosts our tourism economy, and many businesses simply will not survive into the New Year.
  • Other industries who may approach the Scottish Government to present their case for increasing eligibility requirements to include their sector may be in a better position than self-catering to adapt to the coronavirus restrictions. Self-catering has no such luxury: bookings have all but dried up due to travel restrictions affecting the domestic market and those outwith tier 4 areas are ineligible for support. No customers and no government support to tide over operators is an unsustainable position.
  • The ASSC fully recognise that there will be a whole host of competing demands on government funding during these challenging times. However, a key component of Scotland’s tourism industry is in dire need of financial support and we therefore ask that the eligibility requirements are widened so that self-catering businesses across all levels can gain access to desperately needed financial support.

[1] Scottish Government, ‘Coronavirus (COVID-19): Strategic Framework Business Fund’, 10/11/20 Url: https://www.gov.scot/publications/coronavirus-covid-19-strategic-framework-business-fund/pages/eligibility/

[2] Scottish Government, Coronavirus (COVID-19): strategic framework business fund – information for local authorities, 19/11/20. Url: https://www.gov.scot/publications/coronavirus-covid-19-strategic-framework-business-fund—information-for-local-authorities/pages/eligible-businesses/

 

UPDATED: Coronavirus (COVID-19): Guidance for Festive Period (issued:26/11/20)

The Scottish Government has published its guidance on restriction relaxations between 23rd and 27th December.  The guidance stipulates that Christmas bubbles (no more than three households) should be kept to a maximum of eight people (children under 12 are exempt from the rules); those bubbles are not allowed to visit restaurants, bars or tourist accommodation.

During the Christmas period those who are part of a bubble should not stay in tourist accommodation.  Only those not part of a bubble should plan on staying in tourist accommodation and should follow the tourist accommodation, socialising and travel rules in the local authority area you are staying. For example:

  • you should only stay with your own household (or extended household) in self-catering accommodation
  • you must not travel into or out of a level 3 or 4 area for tourist accommodation

Those who have formed a bubble should only socialise in a hospitality, leisure or entertainment venue in your own household (or extended household) for the duration of the festive period.

Socialising and opening hours for pubs, bars, restaurants and cafes are as per the local authority protection levels that the venue is situated in.

Christmas bubbles can only gather in a private home, outdoors or at a place of worship.

See the Scottish Government’s guidance on travel and transport .

See the UK Government’s guidance on Making a Christmas Bubble with Family and Friends. This states that “You can stay in private rented accommodation with members of your household, or your Christmas bubble”.

We are seeking urgent clarification on this updated guidance and will provide more details as soon as possible:

The Scottish Government seem to have completely changed the definition from self-catering which was previously (from 24th September) defined as a private dwelling, therefore limited to one household and not able to utilise the 6/2 rule.  Now, despite relaxation of rules for 5 days over Christmas, allowing an 8/3 people to households ratio, the definition has now changed and self-catering accommodation is no longer a private dwelling.  There must be some consistency if the regulations and Scottish Government guidance are to be taken seriously by our members, the hospitality sector and the public in general.

Response from the Scottish Government 26th November: “I’ve been in touch with a few colleagues regarding your queries about self-catering accommodation over the festive period.  I’m afraid with tomorrow being a public holiday, we won’t be able to provide a full and considered response until early next week.  This is because the festive guidance and advice on social bubbles etc. has been guided by clinical and public health advisers and we will need their expert input and feedback. I know that you were (understandably) keen to provide an update to your members prior to the weekend and am sorry not to be able to assist within these timescales.  We’ll be following this up as a matter of urgency early next week however.”

Scottish Government Updated Guidance: Coronavirus (COVID-19): Guidance for Festive Period (issued:26/11/20)

 

 

 

Scapegoating Short-Term Rentals Won’t Solve the Housing Crisis

There’s a housing crisis in this country. Scotland, and our capital city in particular, just doesn’t have houses available to meet the needs of our population. This lack of housing represents one of the biggest challenges that we face as a country and, without doubt, something must be done about it – and soon. It is simply too important a problem to be allowed to get much worse.

However, before we can begin to resolve this situation, we must understand how it came about in the first place. If our medicine is to work, and for future generations of Scots, and it must, we have to understand how the patient became ill and what their symptoms are.

Sadly, in the context of the housing crisis, this is where our politicians and pressure groups make a huge mistake as they continually misdiagnose the problem and how it came about. Driven by a variety of different individuals, from fringe politicians to respected figures in the property business, some opinion-makers have decided that there is a direct relationship between the number of short-term rentals in Scotland, especially in Edinburgh, and the housing crisis.

Whether they are spurred on by their own self-interest, politically motivated reasoning, or the need to feel relevant, their diagnosis is the same – short-term rentals have caused the housing crisis. No ifs, no buts (and nothing to do with housing cuts).

Far from being just an innocent mistake, the promotion of this falsehood has serious implications. For the same reason that a misdiagnosis has serious ramifications for a patient, without meaningful action, things will get worse.

The truth is that the short-term rental market, while it is worth £50million to Edinburgh and £723million to Scotland as a whole, actually accounts for a tiny percentage of housing stock, according to our recently published report, Far More Than Just Houses. In fact, according to National Reports statistics, there are five times as many empty properties in Scotland than there are self-catering properties. Short-term rentals simply aren’t there in sufficient numbers to have a significant impact on housing supply.

What has led to the housing crisis is the fact that not enough houses have been built.

While the crisis is not the fault of any one government or party, there is blame that must be shouldered if we are to address the problem like a grown-up country.

The governments of the 1970s through to the 1980s oversaw a massive reduction in housing construction – a trend carried on through the 1990s and the 2000s by successive administrations. This is understandable as governments face competing pressures and committing to housebuilding is a large commitment for any government to undertake; but the facts are the facts and we’ve seen a reduction in housing stock and a steady increase in population. Compared to these factors, whatever increase in short-term rentals there may have been in Scotland or anywhere else is insignificant.

The motivation is perfectly clear, even if it is not justifiable; it is far easier to make a scapegoat out of an industry than it is to look back on the past decades of housing policy and conclude that monumental, era-defining, mistakes have been made in planning and execution. To blame short-term rentals is easy, simple, and can be morphed into a moral crusade for people to get irate and indignant about. A good, hard, honest look at housing policy is difficult.

We at the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers, Scotland’s only trade body representing the traditional short-term rental sector, have an interest in being represented accurately and for all the issues that effect our sector to be handled sensibly and with vision. The scapegoating in the name of finding an easy answer that we’ve encountered is as far removed from this as could be.

Rather than taking cheap-shots at the people who make their livelihoods and support their families in our historic industry, which is as important a part of our compelling and world-beating Scottish tourism offering as any other, policymakers and influencers would be better placed using their sway to get on with the job of building more houses for those who need them. Committing to this would be a bold and difficult decision to make but, as the old adage says, nothing worth having ever came easy.

The number of Scots who are facing housing insecurity is too high. Now is the time for action on housing stock and to stop blaming a sector whose impact on that supply is negligible. Scots deserve better and any politician who took the initiative and worked to help them would have the support of the ASSC and all of our members across Scotland.

Fiona Campbell
Chief Executive, Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers