Financial Support for Tourism

Financial Support for Tourism was discussed at Tourism Questions in Parliament today, with the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Tourism:

Hotels (Support)

Jackie Baillie (Dumbarton) (Lab): To ask the Scottish Government what support it has provided for hotels during the Covid-19 pandemic. (S5O-04835)

The Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Tourism (Fergus Ewing): Hotels across Scotland have been severely impacted, which is why we established the dedicated hotel support programme, with £14 million of dedicated funding. In addition, some hotels have had 100 per cent rates relief and access to grants for closed and impacted businesses. I assure Ms Baillie and other members that we are doing all that we can to support hotels with the resources that we have.

Jackie Baillie: The cabinet secretary will know that the hotel support programme was vastly oversubscribed and that many hotels in my constituency and across Scotland have not received any support whatsoever, so they are really struggling. Although the £2,000 and £3,000 grants that have been announced are most welcome, that does not even begin to touch the sides of the issues that hotels face. What more can the cabinet secretary do to help before those hotels go to the wall?

Fergus Ewing: The hotel fund, which was designed to help support the retention of around 3,000 jobs, was designed for the hotels with the largest payrolls—those with a minimum of 50 staff overall, I think.

Ms Baillie is correct to say that many hotels face enormous pressures. She and I have discussed the plight of hotels in her constituency on numerous occasions. I am extremely sympathetic to that. The one-off payments of £2,000 or £3,000—the amount will depend on rateable value—in January will assist hotels to deal with the difficult time of year.

In addition, further support of more than £60 million will be provided to the tourism sector. Details of that are being developed with representatives of the various segments of business, and I hope to make an announcement on those details as soon as possible.

The Deputy Presiding Officer:  David Torrance has a supplementary question.

David Torrance (Kirkcaldy) (SNP): What discussions is the cabinet secretary having with the sector about further support?
Fergus Ewing:  Such discussions take place almost all the time. On Monday, we had detailed discussions with some of Scotland’s leading chefs. This morning, I had discussions with leading tourism voices in Aberdeen. I am in regular discussion with Marc Crothall of the Scottish Tourism Alliance, Fiona Campbell of the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers, Stephen Montgomery in respect of the hospitality side, Wildland Scotland and Sail Scotland. Those discussions take place because we need to work as closely as possible with business to ensure that we provide the most effective support in the most effective way, without it having unintended consequences. I am very grateful to all the business representatives who freely give their time to help us with that essential task.

Cut Tourism VAT Campaign: Urgent Survey

The ASSC and our colleagues at PASC UK are committed supporters of the Cut Tourism VAT Campaign.

The Cut Tourism VAT (CTV) Campaign was set up to lobby for the rate of VAT applying to UK tourism and hospitality to be reduced from 20% to 5%. This would end the sector’s competitive disadvantage compared to other European countries, all of which (excluding Denmark) apply reduced rates to visitor accommodation, and most do so to attractions and meals out.

In July 2020, taking on board the case that the CTV Campaign has made over many years, the Chancellor cut VAT to 5% on tourism and hospitality as an emergency measure to counter the effects of Covid-19.

This reduction is due to be reversed in April 2021. The case being put forward by the CTV Campaign is that VAT at 5% on tourism and hospitality is good for the UK Government and British people in the long term as well as short, and therefore the reduction should not be reversed.

http://www.cuttourismvat.co.uk

To assess the validity of this case, the CTV Campaign, together with the Tourism Alliance and UK Hospitality, is asking sector operators to participate in this short survey, which should take no more than 5 to 10 minutes to complete. All responses will be treated as confidential and the identity of individual respondents will not be revealed. Please fill in the short survey here.

https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/9CHZNCQ

Responses are required please by midnight on FRIDAY 18th DECEMBER.

Local Authority Responses to the Scottish Government STL Consultation

While this consultation was never about whether respondents support/opposed licensing, some of the comments from local authorities on the impact of licensing are really quite stark. The Scottish Government maintain that the fees charged will make the system cost neutral but the local councils clearly state that does not address:

  • The initial costs of setting up licensing schemes – are the SG going to fund this?
  • The impact of Covid-19 on local authorities from a financial and personnel perspective and how this will be impacted by the additional burden of licensing.

It should be noted that some of the respondents below may actually support licensing in general but have concerns about its implementation at the current time and without it being properly resourced. So we can’t necessarily say x or y council opposes licensing overall.

COSLA

“It will be necessary to understand the administrative burden that this may place on local authorities and how this will be resourced.”

https://consult.gov.scot/housing-services-policy-unit/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme/consultation/view_respondent?_b_index=900&uuId=552786991

Aberdeen City Council

“We believe that the 12-month lead-in time to establish our Short-term Let regime will be resource intensive and there will be no ability to recruit additional staff when resources aren’t available until licence applications are submitted and fees paid. This poses staffing issues for the council. Consequently, we believe that the Scottish Government should fund the start-up costs.”

https://consult.gov.scot/housing-services-policy-unit/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme/consultation/view_respondent?_b_index=480&uuId=738532527

Borders Council

“…it is considered essential that Scottish Government provide specific funding for additional resources required by LA’s to cover the initial set up costs, including the transitional and compliance elements of the new legislation.”

https://consult.gov.scot/housing-services-policy-unit/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme/consultation/view_respondent?show_all_questions=0&sort=submitted&order=ascending&_q__text=borders&uuId=648059965

Comhairle nan Eilean Siar

“We have no indication of what the full impact of any COVID-19 fallout will be as the situation is ongoing. Economic recovery may be protracted and we may be dependent on our Tourism Sector to inject life into our economy. Providing us with as much flexibility as possible with regard to regulations would help us in the long term.”

“The evidence gathering, consultation and mechanism to set up a control area will require resourcing, finance and additional staff time to deal with retrospective planning applications where these are required during the transitional period. This legislation will have significant implications for both Development Plans & Development Management, ever diminishing teams against a background of annual budget cuts.

The issue of enforcing regulations and the extra work this will entail is likely to fall on Planning and Licencing staff. In the current climate, the Comhairle is undergoing consultations on cuts that will need to be made to balance support given during lockdown. There is no budget available currently for the recruiting and training of staff and although it is anticipated that potential fees will pay for any staff, there is an initial outlay required, which has not been planned for in budgets. We propose an initial start-up grant or loan from Scottish Government.

Each application would require due consideration and income from planning fees for Change of Use, at current levels, would be unlikely to cover additional staff time for this work.”

“Paragraph 6.4 all local authorities must have a live licencing scheme open to receive licensing applications by 1 April 2022.
• There are 18 months until this needs to be in place, and probably about 12 months once we know the outcome of this consultation and see guidance in the spring. There are policies to be written, consultations to be carried out with public and stakeholders, committees to seek approval from, staff to be employed and trained etc. We are still working from home and under restriction, and with the best will in the world, 18 (or 12) months to get everything underway, when we don’t know what is happening with our workplace, or indeed the way we are working, seems ambitious. We propose the deadline is pushed back by one year.”

https://consult.gov.scot/housing-services-policy-unit/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme/consultation/view_respondent?_b_index=780&uuId=458288928

Glasgow City Council

“It is anticipated that there will be significant resourcing issues for the Local Authority in setting up a licensing scheme. Significant staff resourcing for set of scheme/verification process/carrying out inspections/enforcement etc. would be required.”

https://consult.gov.scot/housing-services-policy-unit/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme/consultation/view_respondent?_b_index=900&uuId=52867059

 Highland Council

“The new regulatory responsibility of both licensing and control areas are anticipated to have significant, budgetary and regulatory impacts on the Highland Council; invoking responsibilities in relation to the status and safety of a very large number of properties across a dispersed geographical area…”

Highland Council also estimate that they could receive as much as “10,000 potential applications” on licensing and that while the “scheme permits a phased approach over a 3-year period but this will still present considerable administrative and operational undertaking for dealing with the initial applications. Ongoing resource will then be needed for renewals and new premises.

The workload will necessitate additional staff for the following teams:
• Licensing team – additional administrative licensing staff
• Planning team – additional full-time posts (professional support officers) for a two-year period. There would still be resource required after this two-year period to cover new and renewed licence enquiries, however this is anticipated to be at a much lower level.
• Environmental Health additional full-time posts (technical officers) for a two-year period. There would still be resource required after this two-year period to cover new and renewed licence enquiries, however this is anticipated to be at a much lower level.
• ICT systems – a review of the on-line tools to enable self-service and on-line payments to streamline the application and payment process.”

https://consult.gov.scot/housing-services-policy-unit/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme/consultation/view_respondent?_b_index=840&uuId=880423694

North Ayrshire Council

“Councils are to set up a new system, complete with new conditions and an inspection system involving Housing, Protective Services and Planning by 1 April 2022 at the latest. This would be a substantial task at any time, but it is particularly onerous when Council staff, working remotely, are facing increased demands to provide services to the public due to the coronavirus pandemic and Councils are facing unprecedented challenges, particularly with regard to licensing due to the coronavirus pandemic.

(a) if premises are to be inspected, Council staff must be available for this;

(b) Council staff are already having to work under pressure as the Coronavirus restrictions are regularly changed. In the case of STLs, where there are objections or representations to Licence Applications, delegated powers are not available to Council officers and the Application must be considered by the Licensing Committee. If there are to be around 327 Applications in North Ayrshire, then a portion of them will need a ‘virtual hearing’ compliant with ECHR 6. This would place a burden on Licensing Authorities at a time when they are least able to bear it.

2.2. Although Councils will be able to choose when the licencing scheme will start locally, it must be within 12 months after 1 April 2021.

2.3. The new STL system commences at most 18 months away, and Councils have not seen the secondary legislation on which the new system will be based. It will be laid in Parliament in December 2020 and has not been issued in draft. It has not been stated whether Application forms and other documentation will be prescribed, or whether they are to be drafted by individual Councils.”

https://consult.gov.scot/housing-services-policy-unit/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme/consultation/view_respondent?_b_index=780&uuId=560815682

South Ayrshire Council

“…there is an element of concern regarding the proposed lead in time for implementation of a robust licencing regime, the resources this will require and the added pressure to workloads required of staff and services.”

https://consult.gov.scot/housing-services-policy-unit/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme/consultation/view_respondent?_b_index=900&uuId=900902345

Stirling Council

“The implementation, management and enforcement of the [licensing] process is considered particularly resource intensive for local authorities, with little guidance given around who would be expected to lead the process.”

https://consult.gov.scot/housing-services-policy-unit/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme/consultation/view_respondent?_b_index=900&uuId=465853950

West Dunbartonshire Council

“For smaller authorities with fewer short term let premises it may be difficult to fully resource an effective and efficient service without the fees being very high and thereby creating a wide and varying fee structure across the country. There is a concern about the level of Fees that a smaller Local Authority may charge where they are not dealing with a large volume of applications and have limited resources to deal with such applications. The fee structure may not be of a sufficient level to meet resource concerns and the adverse comparisons by the public as to differing fee structures around the country as can happen in Civic Government Licensing.”

https://consult.gov.scot/housing-services-policy-unit/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme/consultation/view_respondent?show_all_questions=0&sort=submitted&order=ascending&_q__text=West+Dunbartonshire+Council&uuId=124670121

Read more about the impact of the proposals on local authorities.