ASSC response to Scottish Government Strategic Framework Update

The Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers (ASSC) is extremely disappointed at the lack of clarity about when the tourism sector in Scotland may finally reopen under the Scottish Government’s new Strategic Framework Update.

There is absolutely no detail about an eventual pathway which would enable self-catering operators to work towards planning reopening their business. Despite being a key sector of the Scottish economy, tourism is barely referenced at all in a near 100-page document.
This situation is in marked contrast to the approach taken by the UK Government who explicitly mention that the self-catering industry might reopen on 12th April at the earliest, subject to criteria being met. This divergence of approach will have serious consequences for the Scottish tourism sector. This is evidenced by the fact that self-catering operators in England are already facing a surge in bookings, and similarly, bookings for foreign travel have jumped markedly. Meanwhile, businesses in Scotland have been contacted by English customers inquiring about holidays but are unable to take bookings due to the lingering uncertainty about sectoral reopening. There are now massive reputational issues for us in Scotland and our continued ability to attract tourism from within the UK may be damaged.
Furthermore, with foreign travel unlikely to be a viable option for the foreseeable future, there is an opportunity to boost the domestic tourism market in Scotland and offer safe and managed holidays for families who deserve a break after months of lockdown. As was the case last summer, the Scottish self-catering industry stands ready to reopen in a safe and responsible manner, supported by government approved cleaning protocols, and boost local economies throughout Scotland that have been damaged by the devastating impact of Covid-19.
Of course, the ASSC recognises that public health is paramount and the approach taken by the Scottish Government must be driven by the data. We are making tremendous progress with the vaccination programme throughout the whole of the UK, including Scotland, and the Scottish Government must consider accelerating plans for reopening the economy if the public health situation continues to improve.
The situation facing the self-catering industry is becoming unsustainable and untenable. If businesses cannot generate income due to restrictions, the Scottish Government must provide adequate financial support. The self-catering sector has yet to see any of the sectoral support package announced on December 21st reach the bank accounts of the 2,000 odd larger self-catering operators that will be eligible. The self-catering sector was excluded from Strategic Framework Business Fund support until we entered Level 4, despite businesses being largely closed by the travel restrictions. There is no certainty that ongoing financial support will be forthcoming once we exit Level 4, and with no bookings in the foreseeable future and a raft of new cancellations and refunds on the back of today’s announcement, many are in a perilous state. In addition, self-catering will not benefit from the top-up grants offered to similar hospitality businesses. This cannot continue.
Overall, I sincerely hope that we can work with you to gain some badly needed clarity around the following three issues:
  1. That the Scottish Government provides detail on when self-catering businesses may reopen in Scotland so businesses can plan ahead and not be disadvantaged compared to their counterparts in England
  2. That the Scottish Government provides assurances that bookings from Scottish and UK holidaymakers can be accommodated so to protect our vital tourism industry; an
  3. That the Scottish Government provides adequate funding to self-catering operators so that jobs and livelihoods can be protected until the sector is allowed to reopen.

ASSC Response to withdrawal of Legislation for Licensing Scheme

The CEO of the Association of Self-Caterers Fiona Campbell said:

“The Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers welcomes the withdrawal of the Licensing Order by the Scottish Government. We consistently warned that the proposed legislation was not fit for purpose, would entail unintended consequences for our vital tourism industry and would heap costs on small businesses at a time when they could least afford it.”

“The ASSC commits to working constructively with the Scottish Government and other stakeholders through the new Working Group to ensure that anything that is taken forward in June – whatever the electoral outcome – is measured and proportionate, and also works to support the recovery of Scottish tourism in these challenging times.”

“Scottish Agritourism would like to thank the Association of Scotland’s Self Caterers and in particular their Chief Executive, Fiona Campbell for tirelessly and meticulously campaigning for the short term let legislation to be dropped. Although this has not been dropped, the delay until June does signify that there is multi-party feeling that this legislation will have a significant negative impact on tourism, not just the self-catering and B&B sector.

Scottish Agritourism have put their name to correspondence along with many others representing Scottish tourism to support this lobbying led by the ASSC.” Caroline Millar, Scottish Agritourism

In the News…

Scottish Conservative Local Government Spokesperson Annie Wells said:
“At long last the SNP Government have listened to the lobbying from tourism businesses and the Scottish Conservatives to withdraw these plans.

“However, they have failed to do the right thing and go further by committing that this is the end of the road for these regulations.

“If these regulations are brought back after the election, Scottish Conservative MSPs will stand with the industry and vote to scrap this illogical legislation.

”Scottish Labour Spokesperson for Local Government and Lothian MSP Sarah Boyack:

“This screeching U-turn is the result of the SNP’s failure to listen to the genuine concerns of the tourism sector and Scotland’s hard-pressed local authorities. Scottish Labour supports the regulation of short-term lets, but the SNP’s proposal, as it stood, risked unjustly penalising our tourism sector and foisting greater responsibilities onto our hard-pressed councils without providing any new support. We are in the midst of a housing crisis in Scotland, with 32,000 homes lost to short-term lets from 2016-2019 and communities left hollowed out black of action.  Nonetheless, the SNP’s plans were not fit for purpose. We need an effective licensing scheme that has been developed in partnership with the tourism sector and our councils, that can successfully tackle the damage done by years of de-regulation. It’s time for Kevin Stewart to go back to the drawing board and put together a proper plan to regulate short-term lets that does not penalise our tourism sector or put more pressure on our over-burdened councils.”

Scottish Government Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Kate Forbes MSP:

I recognise that concerns have been raised by many B&Bs and self-catering properties in the Highlands about the impact of this legislation. I have listened to those concerns, relayed them to the Housing Minister and I’m pleased that he has acted in this way. The stakeholder working group will continue to explore the issues and considering solutions. It’s important that work continues. The purpose was to ensure standardised health and safety measures across Scotland which would not have been onerous as most tourism operators already meet such standards. However, I recognise that it has been a very difficult year for tourism, and it’s important that we listen to the industry. I’m sure the debates about the right balance between housing for local residents and visitor accommodation in the Highlands will continue.” (Strathspey Herald)

Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Tourism, Jamie Halcro Johnston MSP:

“Our tourism businesses have been devastated by the pandemic and the last thing they needed was being burdened by more regulations. Our small business owners are the lifeblood of Scotland’s economy and need to be supported by SNP Ministers rather than vilified. Our tourism industry needs to rebuild, rather than be strangled by red tape. Threatening to bring back these regulations in a matter of months fails to give the guarantees tourism businesses across rural Scotland have been crying out for in order to allow them to prosper going forward.” (Scottish Conservative Press Release, 18.2.21)

Liam McArthur MSP
“This is very welcome, though perhaps not surprising as it was looking increasingly likely that the Scottish Government was set to lose the vote on the licencing scheme in parliament. It isn’t yet clear what impact the withdrawal will have for deadlines contained in the legislation, but I will endeavour to keep you informed as things develop.
Obviously, this news will come as a relief to many small tourism businesses in Orkney but I have also stated that any revised proposals must only be brought forward after proper consultation with rural and islands businesses. “

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Read more about the Licensing withdrawal from Scottish Parliament Here 

 

Legislation for Licensing Scheme withdrawn from Scottish Parliament

The following announcement has today (18th February 2021) been made by Scottish Government

Legislation for a short-term lets licensing scheme has been withdrawn from the Scottish Parliament to allow for draft guidance to be developed.

A stakeholder working group has been established to help develop the guidance and meets today for the first time. The guidance will help to provide reassurance on the operation of the scheme to operators and hosts in the sector.

Subject to the outcome of the election, the Scottish Government intends to re-lay the legislation before Parliament in June, accompanied by the draft guidance, to ensure that the timetable on introducing licensing remains the same.

The Government will continue with legislation allowing councils to establish short-term let control areas. This legislation will empower local authorities to implement short-term let control areas, if they wish to do so, to address pressures created by whole property short-term lets, ensuring that homes are used to best effect in their areas.

Letter from Kevin Stewart MSP

SHORT-TERM LETS: LICENSING ORDER

I am writing to advise you that I have decided to withdraw the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 (Licensing of Short-term Lets) Order 2021. This Government’s intention, subject to the outcome of the election, is to re-lay the Order in June and keep to the timetable we have set out.

This will allow us to address the concerns raised by Members who are not content to pass this Order presently by ensuring we can also provide the draft guidance on the licensing scheme with the new Order. This will also provide further time to address the points raised by the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee and make any other adjustments needed to the Order following further stakeholder engagement.

As you know, we have established a stakeholder working group to develop guidance on the licensing scheme and control areas that is clear, comprehensive and easy to understand. The first meeting of the working group is taking place today. The work of that group will continue as planned and it will actively explore solutions to issues raised by operators, with a view to identifying any changes to the legislation that may be needed.

This revised approach will facilitate Members in understanding how the concerns of operators and hosts have been addressed and in seeing, through the draft guidance, how the licensing scheme will operate in practice.

I remain firmly of the view that legislation is needed and I want to reassure affected residents and communities across Scotland of our commitment to deliver this, subject to the outcome of the election.

Our proposals to licence short term lets were developed in response to many concerns raised by residents in communities across Scotland and also by Members in all parties. Our proposals provide local authorities with the powers they need to balance community needs and concerns with wider economic and tourism interests that best suit their communities. Safety of those using short term lets is vital and our proposals will ensure that all short-term lets across Scotland adhere to a common set of safety standards as well as allowing local authorities to tackle issues such as antisocial behaviour. I want to emphasise that our proposals and timetable remains the same, giving councils time to tailor their scheme to local needs and we know they want to take action to protect visitors and residents.

Therefore, this government remains committed to the following dates which are set out in the Order:

  • 1 April 2022 – for local authorities to open a licensing scheme;
  • 1 April 2023 – for all existing hosts to have made an application for a licence; and
  • 1 April 2024 – for all hosts providing short-term let accommodation in Scotland to belicensed.

    We will also use this additional time to work with hosts and operators and local authorities to make sure the licensing scheme is as efficient and effective as it can be.

    We are continuing with the Town and Country Planning (Short-term Let Control Areas) (Scotland) Regulations 2021 and I hope that the Scottish Parliament will approve this instrument.

    I would also like to place on record my thanks to the Committee for their work in consideration of both the Licensing Order and Control Area Regulations.

    I hope the Committee finds this information helpful and I am copying this to Business Managers.

    Kind regards

    KEVIN STEWART