Scaremongering: The Duplicitous Approach to Short-Term Let Licensing

The ASSC is saddened to report a range of quotes from the Scottish Government which illustrates the extremely duplicitous nature of their approach, as well as just some of the absurd points mentioned in the Business Regulatory Impact Assessment.

Scottish Government Quotes

The Cabinet Secretary for Housing Shona Robison MSP on the Working Group, June 2021:

“The stakeholder working group was also tasked with considering any necessary changes to the legislation, ahead of laying the revised Licensing Order, alongside draft guidance, in June.

The stakeholder working group met in February, March and May and has provided significant input into shaping the guidance, and suggesting changes to the legislation. I am grateful to all working group members for sharing their time, knowledge and expertise with my officials, in order to help us get the legislation and guidance right.

We have made a number of changes to the legislation based on suggestions made by members of the stakeholder working group…This government has always stressed striking the balance between the needs of local communities and wider economic and tourism interests. I believe our proposals, having been refined and improved following feedback from the working group, do this.”[1]

  • The Working Group has made no substantive changes to the legislation for the main groups affected – self-catering and B&Bs – and some guest houses will now be captured by the regulations.
  • Moreover, the Scottish Government have added provisions which will make the revised legislation worse for professional operators, having a negative impact on their livelihoods.
  • The Working Group merely paid lip service to the industry stakeholder concerns and made cosmetic changes to the regulations.

Shona Robison MSP, Portfolio Question Time, 16th June 2021:

“Local authorities have been involved in the discussions and will set the fees to cover their costs in establishing and administering the scheme. I reassure the member that we do not expect the fees to be onerous. The business and regulatory impact assessment contains an estimated range of between £223 and £377 to cover a three-year licence, which I do not regard as overly onerous.”[2]

  • A representative from SOLAR (Society of Local Authority Lawyers & Administrators in Scotland) on the Working Group suggested that the scheme would have to run on a cost recovery basis and could cost in the region of £1,500-£2,000 per licence.
  • Local Authorities are encouraged to increase fees for larger properties and different styles of short-term let.

Kate Forbes MSP, Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy on the withdrawal of the Scottish Government’s licensing plans, February 2021:

“I recognise that concerns have been raised by many B&Bs and self-catering properties in the Highlands about the impact of this legislation.

I have listened to those concerns, relayed them to the Housing Minister and I’m pleased that he has acted in this way.

The stakeholder working group will continue to explore the issues and considering solutions. It’s important that work continues.

The purpose was to ensure standardised health and safety measures across Scotland which would not have been onerous as most tourism operators already meet such standards.

However, I recognise that it has been a very difficult year for tourism, and it’s important that we listen to the industry…”[3]

  • Back in February 2021, and prior to the election, the Cabinet Secretary welcomed the withdrawal of the licensing regulations, noting that she had relayed concerns from tourist accommodation providers to the Housing Minister, and stressed the importance of listening to industry.

Kate Forbes MSP, July 2021:

  • However, by July 2021, the Cabinet Secretary took a somewhat different stance, implying that some were propagating “unfounded fears”.

“Whilst it [short-term let regulation] is a complex and multi-faceted problem with no easy answers, I hope that the debate centres around facts rather unfounded fears.

Furthermore, if we are serious about tackling the Highlands housing crisis, then I believe that this needs to be a much broader discussion than previously…

The Scottish Government has been clear that a very basic health and safety scheme will be established, as is the case for nearly every other business and sector in Scotland. and this will be the last opportunity for the various stakeholder groups – be it tourism accommodation providers or those who can’t find a place to stay in their home area – to comment and help shape the final proposal.”[4]

  • The Scottish Government have stated that the consultation focuses on the health and safety of short-term lets yet the debate is being widened out to include housing, an issue already covered by the planning control zone regulations in the Planning Act.
  • The ASSC and others are not promulgating “unfounded fears” but are conveying genuine concern at the provisions of these disproportionate licensing plans which will be materially damaging to Scottish tourism.
  • In 2017, the ASSC pro-actively suggested a mandatory registration scheme with health & safety, accompanied by a licensing scheme in areas where there is a demonstrable link between short-term letting and loss of housing stock (underpinned by real time data from the registration scheme). This could have been delivered via the Development of Tourism Act 1969 with no additional legislation. This recommendation was ignored.

“How can the negative impact of Licensing on the short-term let sector be mitigated or avoided?”

The Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers (ASSC) held its first ever hustings ahead of the 2021 Holyrood elections, on 7th April. Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Tourism, Fergus Ewing, representing the SNP said:

“I do think they need to be mitigated. This has caused a lot of concern. The regulations were intended largely to deal with problems that exist regarding anti-social behaviour of party flats in Edinburgh, and there is a feeling that the knock-on unintended consequences are affecting self-catering, B&B and guest houses throughout the country.

I believe that we were right to withdraw the regulations from Parliament and that Kevin Stewart was correct to say that there needs to be a reappraisal. I am determined that if I continue to be a Minister, that I will make sure that these regulations are not imposed in a way that is overly burdensome and disproportionate and I also do think that there is a case for looking at your proposal of a registrations scheme which could be an alternative.

I think much more talking needs to be done, in an open and straightforward way and I do think that the Working Group which is set up contains an awful lot of the right people.

But I think we need to make sure that self-catering, B&B and guest houses which quite frankly have not caused any anti-social behaviour to anybody. As an MSP for 22 years, I have not received a single complaint against a B&B or guest house. The only self-catering issues that arrive, I think, are from party flats for groups of 20 – 30 people.

There is a lot of discussion to be done across party to make sure that we do not create something that causes financial burden and regulatory burden and also uncertainties with regard to things such as future planning permission. We need to eliminate all of these negatives and focus on positives, which is simply ensuring that guests are properly and safely protected and I think frankly, in respect of self-catering, they already are.”

Find out what all the candidates had to say on the subject: ASSC Hustings – Short-Term Let Position

Watch the Hustings. This is covered from 20:30 mins in.

  • To suggest to Ministers, or indeed the electorate, that the Working Group has delivered anything meaningful to the legislation, guidance, or indeed BRIA is disingenuous at best and duplicitous at worse.
  • The Licensing Order was withdrawn in February because it was not fit for purpose, with cross party support. It is still not fit for purpose. Indeed it is worse than the original.

Scottish Government 2021 Business Regulatory Impact Assessment (BRIA)

The BRIA makes a number of astonishing claims about the “social costs” of short-term lets, including:

“use of short-term let accommodation for criminal enterprises (such drug dealing, sex trafficking etc.), with or without the collusion of the host.” [5]

  • There is no empirical data to suggest criminal use within short-term lets and this is simply anecdote. It is also insulting to professional self-caterers to even suggest such nonsense.
  • The BRIA also appears to favour other forms of accommodation, such as hotels (which are not licensed in terms of health & safety), over the self-catering sector and ludicrously claims that those displaced by a reduction in STLs could use hotels and hostels:

“Some visitors displaced by a reduction in short-term let capacity may use other forms of accommodation, such as hotels and hostels. This may also encourage the further provision of these types of accommodation.”[6]

  • It is not logical or practical to suggest that hotels or hostels could replace the accommodation provided by short-term lets and self-catering in rural and remote parts of Scotland.
  • The danger is that this displacement will increase the prevalence of motorhomes on our rural roads, bringing little local economic value, negatively impacting infrastructure and increasing our carbon footprint.

The Scottish Government has no robust data on the scale of short-term letting in Scotland. It will therefore be impossible to monitor and evaluate the success of licensing with no baseline data.[7]

Watch the ASSC / Gilson Gray webinar to find out the reality of this legislation.

Footnotes

[1] Consultation foreword, https://www.gov.scot/binaries/content/documents/govscot/publications/consultation-paper/2021/06/short-term-lets-consultation-draft-licensing-order-business-regulatory-impact-assessment-bria/documents/short-term-lets-consultation-draft-licensing-order-business-regulatory-impact-assessment-bria/short-term-lets-consultation-draft-licensing-order-business-regulatory-impact-assessment-bria/govscot%3Adocument/short-term-lets-consultation-draft-licensing-order-business-regulatory-impact-assessment-bria.pdf

[2] https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/what-was-said-and-official-reports/what-was-said-in-parliament/meeting-of-parliament-16-06-2021?meeting=13238&iob=119984

[3] https://www.strathspey-herald.co.uk/news/short-term-lets-legislation-withdrawn-by-scottish-government-228610/

[4] https://www.ross-shirejournal.co.uk/news/highland-holiday-rentals-in-spotlight-as-public-urged-to-hav-243710/

[5] https://www.gov.scot/binaries/content/documents/govscot/publications/impact-assessment/2021/06/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme-planning-control-area-legislation-draft-business-regulatory-impact-assessment-bria/documents/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme-planning-control-area-legislation-draft-business-regulatory-impact-assessment-bria-consultation/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme-planning-control-area-legislation-draft-business-regulatory-impact-assessment-bria-consultation/govscot%3Adocument/short-term-lets-licensing-scheme-planning-control-area-legislation-draft-business-regulatory-impact-assessment-bria-consultation.pdf

[6] Ibid

[7] Ibid

Should Edinburgh be a Short-Term Let Control Area?

City of Edinburgh Council has issued the following press release:

A consultation is set to begin next month following consideration of a report published today outlining a draft proposal to designate the whole city as a short term let (STL) control area.

If, following the consultation, the Council gives the go ahead and the proposal is approved by the Scottish Government, the new powers would mean all residential properties, which are not an owner’s principle home, being let as STLs in their totality throughout the local authority area would require approval of a ‘change of use’ to a STL from Planning.

Around a third of STLs in Scotland are in Edinburgh.  At the moment, in addition to planning applications made for STLs, to establish whether or not planning permission is required for properties where this is disputed, the Council’s enforcement team looks at each case individually, which is a very lengthy and time consuming process.

The introduction of powers to make a control area, follows the Council calling for new legislation to tighten up the control of STLs to help manage high concentrations of secondary letting where it affects the availability of residential housing or the character of a neighbourhood.

Also, it will help to restrict or prevent STLs in places or types of buildings where they are not appropriate as well as making sure homes are used to best effect in their areas.

If a home has been changed to secondary letting and continually operated as a STL for more than 10 years before a STL control area is designated and no enforcement action has been taken during that time, planning permission is not required. Also, generally, renting out a room/s in your house or letting your property whilst on holiday would also still be allowed if Edinburgh became a STL control zone.

The Scottish Government is currently consulting on legislation to introduce a new licensing regime next year, which the Council also called for, to address the issues of safety, anti-social behaviour and noise. These issues have all had a detrimental effect on communities as the number of STLs has greatly increased across the city in recent years.

The proposal is that all Scottish councils will have to adopt a STL licensing system by October 2022. In terms of the Government’s proposed new licensing regime, if Edinburgh becomes a control area it will be a mandatory condition of any licensing application to have made a planning application or to have planning permission already when providing accommodation that requires it.

Cllr Neil Gardiner, Planning Convener, said:

Last year we welcomed that our call for new Scottish Government legislation to control STLs was successful. If the proposals are approved by the Planning Committee, we’ll be in a position where we can push forward and ask our residents, the industry and other interested groups, for their views on making the whole of Edinburgh a STL control area. We’ll be looking carefully at this feedback before the proposal is finalised as the impact of STLs can be felt in communities across Edinburgh.

If the Scottish Government approve the whole city as a STL control zone, we’ll be able to manage the number of STLs in the city as properties being let out in these areas would automatically require to have ‘change of use’ planning permission in place. It’s also good news that the Scottish Government is proposing that when people apply for a licence we can ask for evidence that they have that planning permission. This is something we’re very keen to do and our ‘Choices’ consultation responses for our next local development plan – ‘City Plan 2030’ – showed overwhelming support for control zones.

Combined with the proposed licensing regime due to be introduced next year, if approved, this step forward is in direct response to our hard work in pushing for the powers we know we need to deliver for our communities city-wide.

Maureen Child, Vice-Convener of the Planning Committee, said:

It’s great to see so much progress being made to tackle this issue we have campaigned so hard to address. This is so important as STLs have reduced the city’s housing stock, hollowed out communities and caused numerous issues for residents such as noise and other anti-social behaviour. I look forward to seeing these new powers being used to improve the lives of many of our residents throughout the city.

Further information

What is a short term let?

Details can be found in Annex B of the Scottish Government’s Planning Circular on Short-Term Let Control Areas.

Background on numbers of STLs

There are a significant number of short-term lets in Edinburgh, with the Airbnb platform providing a useful indicator of the scale of this in the city. In the period 2016-2019 there was a substantial rise in the number of both entire properties and rooms registered with Airbnb. Relative to other areas in Scotland the number of Airbnb listings is high making the impact on the city disproportionate. In 2019, 31% of all Airbnb listings in Scotland were in the city of Edinburgh. The next greatest proportion was 19% in Highland followed by 7% in Glasgow City. This illustrates the magnitude of STLs in Edinburgh in comparison to other areas of Scotland.

Read the Planning Committee Recommendations: Short-Term Let Area of Control

Fiona Campbell, Chief Executive Officer of the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers, said:

“Edinburgh Council’s draft proposals for a short-term let control zone covering the entire city are wholly disproportionate and lack an empirical evidence base to substantiate claims that such accommodation has reduced housing stock.”

“Furthermore, their proposals appear to rely on pre-pandemic listings from one online platform only and this does not provide an accurate reflection of the situation.”

“Self-catering properties have been a longstanding presence in the capital for decades, enhancing the tourist offering and boosting the local economy, and should not be used as a convenient scapegoat for policy failures elsewhere. Communities are being hoodwinked into believing that regulating short-term lets out of existence will act as a panacea when in reality, we have failed to build enough affordable homes or bring large numbers of empty properties back into use.”

“Last year, self-catering generated £50m for Edinburgh’s economy. For a city that is renowned for its hospitality, it is very disappointing that local policymakers are looking to solve multifaceted housing challenges in Edinburgh by concentrating on tourist accommodation and damaging small businesses in the process.”

“The ASSC looks forward to supplying evidence to the upcoming consultation by the Council and highlighting the need for balanced, targeted and proportionate regulation for the benefit of all concerned stakeholders in the city.”

This is the death knell to the professional self-catering sector in Edinburgh.

For some actual facts about the impact of short-term letting on housing stock, read our report.

STL Licensing – What is This Really Going to Cost?

Short-Term Let Licensing for Self-Caterers, B&Bs, Guest Houses, Glamping and other Short-Term Let Accommodation

Key Information on the Scottish Government’s consultation on short-term let licensing, the main issues involved, and what you can do in response.

What is This Really Going to Cost?

  • Local authorities will each determine their own fees and fee structures to recover establishment and running costs specific to their area. This means that the fees charged by local authority will vary. Relevant factors include whether they can achieve economies of scale, rurality and how they integrate their short-term lets licensing scheme with other housing and licensing functions.
  • Different licensing authorities may charge different fees. The exact fee that you need to pay may depend on things like how many guests you want to accommodate. If you have premises in more than one licensing authority area, the fees you pay may be different, even for the same circumstances. If your application is refused, your fee will not be refunded.
  • Local authorities can differentiate their fees dependent on the characteristics of the short-term let. For example, a local authority could charge a different fee based on: the maximum number of guests specified on the licence and whether a property is licensed for (a) secondary letting or (b) home sharing and home letting; this is not an exhaustive list.
  • Other determinations may include: the size of the premises; number of bedrooms; number of guests; duration of the period is it made available for use; and the extent to which the licence holder has complied with the conditions of the licence.
  • The BRIA assessment suggests that the average indicative fee for processing an application will be between £223 and £377.However, a representative from SOLAR (Society of Local
    Authority Lawyers & Administrators in Scotland) on the Working Group suggested that the scheme would have to run on a cost recovery basis and could cost in the region of £1,500-£2,000 per licence.
  • To put this in context, landlord registration fees are set nationally at £67 plus £15 for each property, making the lowest fee £82 for one property. This cost is incurred once every three years.
  • The ASSC has no confidence whatsoever that the fee will be as low as £223, nor how this figure has been set, although it appears to reflect a two bedroomed flat.
  • According to the draft legislation, a local authority may also charge a fee in respect of an inspection. There is no other regime (liquor licensing, building, planning and similar) where premises are charged for an inspection which is a statutory requirement.

Incidentally, no mention is made in the draft Guidance to Hosts and Operators that operating without a licence could result in a fine of £50,000 or imprisonment. Failing to comply with a licence condition, may incur a fine of £10,000.

WHAT YOU CAN DO FOR YOUR BUSINESS AND SCOTLAND’S TOURISM INDUSTRY

It is important to remember that none of this is inevitable. The Scottish Government have changed policies if there is sufficient public pressure, just as they temporarily withdrew the original Licensing Order because of a high level of response from operators like you.

There is a chance they will do so again – but only if there is an unprecedented level of concern. That is why, if you agree with the ASSC’s analysis and are concerned for the future of your business, we would kindly ask you to do 3 things:

  1. Respond to the Scottish Government’s consultation by Friday 13 August 2021 using the following linkhttps://consult.gov.scot/housing-and-social-justice/short-term-lets-draft-licensing-order-and-bria/consultation/subpage.2016-07-07.1474135251/
  1. Contact your regional and constituency MSPs in the first instance and then local authority councillors highlighting the problems with the regulations (you can copy and paste your consultation response) and explaining the likely impact on your business and local supply chain etc. You can find your MSPs using the postcode checker tool on the Scottish Parliament website: https://beta.parliament.scot/msps/current-and-previous-msps
  1. In the correspondence above, please copy us in: communications@assc.co.uk

For more information, watch the ASSC webinar: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0gOivLov7g&t=82s