Edinburgh Council Set to Approve Citywide Short-Term Let Control Area

ALL short-term let properties in Edinburgh not being used as a home are set to be required to obtain planning permission after city officials recommended “to designate the entire council area as a short-term let control area.”.

Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers Chief Executive, Fiona Campbell, said:

“Including the whole of Edinburgh in this restrictive and anti-business scheme will have a hugely detrimental impact on the many small businesses who work tirelessly to ensure that the capital has one of the world’s best tourism offerings.

“The real problem Edinburgh has is a lack of house building, but our local authority has chosen to pick on an easy scapegoat rather than address the real and difficult issue.

“Despite the misrepresentation that we have had to deal with, the ASSC will continue to promote self-catering in Edinburgh and across Scotland and remains committed to finding a policy solution that works for all.”

Read the ASSC response to the Planning Control Zone Consultation: ECC response to Planning Control Zone Legislation

According to the Planning Committee Report, alternatives to Short-Term Lets include:

  • Multiple hotel developments in the city and hosts who let a room in their property add to [tourism accommodation] supply. Regulating the entire property lets should not prevent visitors from coming to the city.
  • Tourist population should be naturally regulated by the number of available hotel and B&B spaces.
  • Demand should be met via development of the dedicated aparthotel sector rather than the removal of residential properties from the long term rental / home ownership market.
  • Better to promote the trend for affordable hotel accommodation to provide safe accommodation.
  • Homeowners letting out rooms and entire properties if they reside in the property the majority of the time will allow for an increase in short term lets for the festival periods.
  • STLs take business away from established guest houses and hotels with inferior facilities risking reputational damage.
  • Places pressure and unfair competition on existing hotel accommodation and similar other businesses, particularly as there is no regulation of short term lets.
  • Declining use of office accommodation means that there are other ways to think about catering for visitors’ accommodation needs.
  • Hotel businesses employ large numbers of people within the city and the uncontrolled growth of the short term let accommodation has affected that employment rate, to the disbenefit of the local economy.

https://democracy.edinburgh.gov.uk/documents/s42696/7.1%20-%20Short-term%20Let%20Area%20of%20Control%20Designation.pdf

https://www.heraldscotland.com/politics/19932235.edinburgh-council-set-approve-citywide-airbnb-short-term-let-control-area/

Parliamentary Questions February 2022

The following written questions and answers have been submitted:

Short-Term Lets

S6W-06372: Liam Kerr, North East Scotland, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date Lodged: 08/02/2022 To ask the Scottish Government whether all short-term holiday let properties will be required to have an EPC rating of C or above by 2025; whether any short-term holiday let properties that do not meet an EPC rating of C or above by the deadline will, as a result, no longer be permitted to be let, and, if so, what it anticipates the financial impact will be on the Scottish tourism industry. Current Status: Expected Answer date 08/03/2022

S6W-06006: Rachael Hamilton, Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date Lodged: 04/02/2022 R To ask the Scottish Government, in light of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 (Licensing of Short-term Lets) Order 2022 and Town and Country Planning (Short-term Let Control Areas) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2022 being approved, whether overall responsibility for oversight of businesses in the short-term letting sector will (a) move to its Housing and Social Justice Directorate and (b) remain within the overall responsibility of the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy. Current Status: Expected Answer date 04/03/2022

S6W-06372: Liam Kerr, North East Scotland, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date Lodged: 08/02/2022 To ask the Scottish Government whether all short-term holiday let properties will be required to have an EPC rating of C or above by 2025; whether any short-term holiday let properties that do not meet an EPC rating of C or above by the deadline will, as a result, no longer be permitted to be let, and, if so, what it anticipates the financial impact will be on the Scottish tourism industry.Current Status: Expected Answer date 08/03/2022

Tourist Tax

S6W-06283: Sarah Boyack, Lothian, Scottish Labour, Date Lodged: 04/02/2022 To ask the Scottish Government when it plans to empower local authorities to introduce a Transient Visitor Levy; whether it will be for local authorities to decide (a) when and (b) how to use such a levy, and whether it will affect the distribution formula of the block grant to local authorities. Current Status: Expected Answer date 04/03/2022

Answers

Self-Catering

S6W-06118: Rachael Hamilton, Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date Lodged: 02/02/2022 To ask the Scottish Government on what date did it last (a) meet and (b) correspond with the UK Government about the provision of support for self-catering businesses that have seen their business disrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Answered by Ivan McKee: While the Scottish Government has not met or corresponded with UK Government on this question specifically, we meet and correspond with UKG regularly about funding in general.

Over the course of the pandemic we have worked closely with the self-catering accommodation sector and Scottish Tourism Alliance on the recovery and support for the sector and we will continue to do so.

The Scottish Government recognises that the self-catering accommodation sector, alongside many other businesses across Scotland has been adversely affected by Covid-19. In addition to the regular Strategic Framework Business Fund which previously supported small accommodation providers, a range of tailored support to meet the needs of tourism businesses was developed. This included the Small Accommodation Providers Paying Council Tax Fund (SAP-CTF) which eligible Bed & Breakfasts, Guesthouses, small serviced accommodation providers and other self-catering businesses that paid council tax were able to access. Other targeted funds included the large self-catering grant and support for the B&B sector via a fund of up to £3 million to support those B&Bs with no business bank account. Equivalent tailored funds have not generally been available in England.

We will continue to engage in dialogue with the UK Government on issues of funding and to monitor the impacts of COVID on Scotland’s tourist industry.

Short-Term Lets

Question S6W-05750: Mark Griffin, Central Scotland, Scottish Labour, Date Lodged: 20/01/2022 To ask the Scottish Government whether it has completed its consideration of how to complete the review of the tax treatment of short-term lets; whether the review is complete, and whether it will (a) publish the review or (b) outline the timetable for completing the review.

Answered by Shona Robison (02/02/2022): During the COVID-19 pandemic we prioritised work on the Short-term lets Licensing Order and Amendment Regulations for short-term let control areas. This enabled the statutory instruments for these to be considered by the Scottish Parliament in this session and meant the review of the tax treatment of short-term lets was deferred.

We intend to recommence the tax treatment review in the coming months to ensure that short-term lets make an appropriate contribution to the communities they operate in.

Update on the Scottish Government’s Re-Constituted Stakeholder Working Group on Short-Term Lets

The Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers (ASSC) has taken the decision to participate in the Scottish Government’s Stakeholder Working Group on Short-Term Lets.

The ASSC, along with other tourism stakeholders, had resigned from the Working Group in August 2021 as it was not fit for purpose. However, circumstances have changed following the Scottish Parliament’s approval of the Licensing Order last month and the fact that the Working Group has now been reconstituted with updated terms of reference.

The purpose of the updated Working Group is to assist the Scottish Government to finalise guidance on the short-term lets licensing scheme and planning control areas, ahead of implementation of licensing schemes from October 2022.

While concerns remain given our experience during the discussions last year, the ASSC believes that we must take cognisance of the changed regulatory context and refocus our efforts to help protect Scotland’s £867m self-catering sector under challenging circumstances.

Our decision should not be taken as an endorsement of the government’s position on licensing. The ASSC continues to maintain that licensing will entail a materially negative impact for Scottish tourism and we will continue to articulate your concerns on this matter.

While there is no guarantee of success, we will work constructively and collaboratively with the Working Group to help facilitate the implementation of this legislation in order to prevent, as much as possible, any unintended consequences.