Planning Control Areas in Edinburgh: Written Answers

QUESTION NO 12 By Councillor Jim Campbell for answer by the Convener of the Planning Committee at a meeting of the Council on 17 March 2022

The Council has promoted its intention to have a Short Term Lets Control Area including in a press release on 23 February 2022.

Given that the changes to Planning rules will not affect properties that have operated in this way for more than 10 years:

Question (1) What number and proportion of short term-lets is it expected will be required to seek planning permission to continue operating?

Answer (1) The automatic requirement for planning permission to operate a short-term let (STL) applies only to letting of a dwelling that is not a principal home, it does not apply to home sharing or home letting. The majority of short-term lets in Edinburgh are entire property lets.

In October 2021, 4,022 entire properties were registered on Airbnb (which is one of the online platforms that enable bookings of short-term lets). This was 77% of all registrations. The forthcoming short-term licensing scheme will require applicants within the short-term let control area to demonstrate planning permission or that it is not required. It is not known how many properties will seek planning permission however from our planning enforcement investigations, it is thought the majority of those operating will have been doing so for less than 10 years.

Question (2) What is the expectation with regard to how many of these may be successful in gaining planning permission?

Answer (2) It is not possible to pre-judge the outcome of planning applications. Current planning policy allows consideration of the appropriateness of short-term letting within a residential context. Where this is appropriate it allows for STLs. In 2021 there were 25 applications for planning permission for STLs determined. 15 of these were granted.

Scottish Labour Manifesto for Edinburgh Local Elections

Scottish Labour in Edinburgh have just released their manifesto for the local government elections in May. It asserts that  Short-Term Lets  “ have been hollowing out our historic city” and have “reduced the number of homes available for purchase or rent by long term tenants and pushed up prices and rents to levels that local people can’t afford.”

In terms of policy commitments, they want a “balance” between tourism and residents by:

  • Using the new planning and licensing powers to control the numbers of short term lets in the city, and put in place effective enforcement.
  • Ensuring that all Council planning and licensing policies give substantial weight to the needs of residents while still encouraging business and tourism.

They also want to:

  • Put pressure on the Scottish Government to use the landlord registration and licensing systems (for HMOs and short term lets) to place obligations on landlords to upgrade energy efficiency.
  • Make Edinburgh a short term letting control zone to limit the numbers of short term lets and pressure the Scottish Government to strengthen the licensing scheme to allow councils to limit the number of licences.

The manifesto is available to view here: https://drscottarthur.files.wordpress.com/2022/03/ed_lab_manifesto_v4_mar22.pdf

Response from the Scottish Government Regarding Planning Control Areas

On 1st March 2022, a group of prominent business leaders and small business owners urged the Scottish Government to reject a cumbersome and restrictive city-wide control area on short-term lets in Edinburgh.

Read more.

Read the response from Scottish Ministers: Response from Tom Arthur.