Tourism Organisations Resign from “not fit for purpose” Scottish Government Working Group on Short-Term Lets

Several of Scotland’s leading tourism organisations have resigned from the Scottish Government’s Working Group on Short-Term Lets, claiming that it has failed to fulfil its remit and branding it not fit for purpose.

Representatives of the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers, the Scottish B&B Association, Airbnb and the UK Short Term Accommodation Association have quit the group en masse citing its inability to address concerns the industry has raised over proposed new measures.

Industry figures have also accused the Scottish Government of deliberately “shifting the goalposts” on its policy intentions and acting with disregard towards the sector, which has suffered immense hardship throughout the COVID-19 pandemic.

Earlier this year, the Scottish Government withdrew its licensing proposals ahead of the election as they were widely recognised as not being fit for purpose, and they committed to respond to stakeholder concerns through the Working Group.

However, the tourism bodies have highlighted the lack of significant changes in the legislation impacting traditional self-catering and B&Bs, as well as homesharers, despite representatives of both sectors acting in good faith, as grounds for quitting the group. In fact, additional provisions have been added to the legislation, with some guest houses now being caught up in the plans.

Further, they have also accused the government, which is now on its third consultation on short-term lets in four years, of acting with “cavalier disregard and indifference” towards the sector’s concerns about the impending restrictive licencing scheme and of ignoring their proposals for a more workable, proportionate and cost-effective mandatory programme of registration.

Nearly half of self-catering operators are expected to leave the sector should the plans come into force, thereby jeopardising the recovery of Scottish tourism from the pandemic.

All the organisations involved in the walk-out have been responsible, willing, and positive parties to the discussions, providing key industry insight and evidence-based analysis, but have been met with obtuse responses and a reluctance to engage, the latest of which represents the final straw for the industry.

Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers Chief Executive, Fiona Campbell, said:

“Despite our best efforts, and those of our colleagues across Scottish tourism, this Working Group has been revealed as nothing but a sham and therefore we have decided to leave it.

“Throughout the entire process, while we have acted in good faith, this government has continually shifted the goalposts and acted with cavalier disregard and indifference towards our sincere concerns and innovative ideas.

“Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, and long-before that, the Scottish tourism industry has been an example for others to follow – it is therefore extremely disappointing that our government has not held itself to the same standards and failed to back small business at this crucial time.”

Chairman of the Bed & Breakfast Association, David Weston, said:

“Leaving the Working Group is not a decision that my colleagues and I have taken lightly but there seems little point in remaining.

“We have been frustrated at every turn and it will be Scottish B&Bs that suffer if we continue to take part in what has become nothing but a charade.

“Our members expect us to act in their best interests, and in the interests of the broader tourism sector, and it has been made abundantly clear that neither the Working Group nor the Scottish Government are interested in that type of dialogue.”

COVID-19 or Other Illness on the Premises

The Scottish Government (SG) has today confirmed that the following guidance is still correct (as confirmed by SG Covid isolation policy colleagues), but there is ongoing work with Public Health Scotland and key health officials within government to review in light of forthcoming changes and to ensure alignment.

I’m aware that Carole proposed some amendments regarding public transport (copied below for ease of comparison).  At the moment Scottish Government are still advocating the avoidance of public transport because of transmission risks.

While this is the current position, this is a live issue and will be updated in light of any announced changes.    

Current and agreed SG position:

COVID-19 or other illness on the premises

In the event that a guest develops symptoms whilst staying away from home, they should immediately book a test through NHS Inform or, if they can’t get online. by phoning 0800 028 2816.

In accordance with Test and Protect, people with symptoms are required to self-isolate for 10 days, and everyone in their household should isolate for 10 days. If the test is negative, everyone can end isolation. If the test is positive, everyone should continue to isolate, and the NHS Test and Protect team will be in touch to start contact tracing. Those contacted through the Test and Protect programme will be required to self-isolate for at least 10 days.

If guests who are isolating can travel home safely to isolate, avoiding the use of public transport, they should do this.

In the event that this is not possible, the guest should discuss this with the NHS Test and Protect team. The guest may be signposted to the National Assistance Helpline on 0800 111 4000 if they need help to isolate and cannot arrange it themselves or through friends and family.

In some circumstances further discussion may be required with the local Health Protection Team and local authority to ensure that the person has suitable accommodation to isolate safely and effectively.

After the required period of self-isolation, guests and anyone else in their party who has been affected can then return to their main place of residence.

Coronavirus (COVID-19): tourism and hospitality sector – gov.scot (www.gov.scot)

What does moving beyond level 0 mean?

We will move beyond level 0 when we meet the gateway condition – which is all over 40’s having been vaccinated and assuming we are meeting our revised strategic aim of alleviating the harm of the virus (expected around 9 August, but subject to confirmation nearer the time).

When we move beyond level 0 and therefore out of the levels framework, almost all COVID restrictions will be removed for businesses and individuals.  This will mean that all businesses can reopen and can operate without restrictions on physical distancing.  For example this will also mean that weddings can take place with dancing and singing and mingling as before the pandemic.

From the indicative date of 9th of August, there will be no household / number caps and physical distancing requirements will also be removed.  This will mean that tourist accommodation will be able to operate on a more ‘business as normal basis’ albeit with appropriate hygiene and ventilation measures.

Please note that these dates are indicative and are dependent on the necessary conditions on vaccination and harm reduction being met.

We will however have to live with the virus for some time to come, so we will be asking people to stick to a set of baseline measures to stop the virus resurging and to protect those who do not have protection from vaccination.  The baseline measures which we currently expect to retain beyond Level 0 include:

  • Good hand hygiene and surface cleaning.
  • Continued promotion of good ventilation.
  • Requirement for face coverings in certain settings. At least for a period, we are likely to require the wearing of face coverings in certain settings – for example, shops and public transport.
  • Continued compliance with Test and Protect, including self-isolation when necessary.
  • Ongoing need for outbreak management capability, including active surveillance.
  • A phased return to the workplace from Level 0 onwards, while encouraging a greater degree of homeworking than pre-pandemic. This will not only assist with controlling transmission of the virus, but also promote wellbeing more generally.

There are also likely to be targeted restrictions on overseas travel beyond Level 0. However, we will keep restrictions in place only for as long as necessary to respond to the threat of importation. These restrictions are reviewed regularly and will be relaxed when it is safe to do so.

Scottish Government colleagues will work with business organisations and sector teams to ensure effective guidance is in place and further detail provided on baseline measures prior to our move beyond level 0.

What is happening with Physical Distancing

  • Physical distancing has been an important measure for helping to control the virus but we recognise that it is has had a severe impact on businesses, both on viability and profitability, and on individuals.
  • Today’s physical distancing review sets out the plan for reducing and then removing physical distancing, subject to confirmation based on data nearer the time.
  • The plan sets out that on the indicative date of 19 July, when the whole of the country is expected to be moved to level 0, the need for physical distancing will be no longer be required outdoors and physical distancing indoors will be reduced to 1m for all public settings.  This means that indoor businesses will be able to work at 1m distancing from 19 July and outdoor parts of businesses will no longer have any physical distancing requirements, subject to confirmation nearer the time.
  • The new physical distancing rules which come into effect on 19 July will no longer require physical distancing between members of friendship / family groups, but they will be required to maintain a distance of at least 1 m from all others.
  • From 19 July – different households will be permitted to share a bedroom – although this will obviously be dependent upon capacity and appropriate bed spaces within rooms.
  • In public spaces within regulated tourist accommodation the rules about socialising indoors in a public space will apply.  In level 0 a maximum of ten people from up to 4 households can socialise indoors in a public place.  Children under the age of 12 from these households do not count towards the number of people permitted to meet but do count towards the number of households.
  • In self-catered or other unregulated accommodation, in house socialising rules apply, in level 0 a maximum of 8 people from up to 4 households can socialise in a private dwelling.  Children under the age of 12 do not count towards the total number of people permitted to meet but do count towards the number of households.
  • If a large room or dormitory room (e.g. within a hostel or other similar venue) is being used by mixed / multiple groupings (but is within the 10/4 socialising rule) then a minimum of 1 m is required between different family and friends groupings.   However, a friendship group sharing a dorm would not have to distance within their own group.  They would however, have to distance from other groups.    It is also important that as we relax the socialising rules, especially indoors, other mitigation factors and good practice regarding good ventilation and hygiene measures are adhered to.

Who can share a bedroom in tourist accommodation? 

From 19 July, with the move to level zero, different households are permitted to share a bedroom – although this will be dependent upon capacity and appropriate bed spaces within rooms.

In shared bedrooms within indoor public settings it should be possible for different households (or extended households) to maintain a physical distance of 1 metre from each other and they are expected to do so. If it is not possible for this distance to be maintained then separate bedrooms are recommended.

In self-catered or other unregulated accommodation, in-house socialising rules apply, while in public spaces within regulated (staffed) tourist accommodation, the rules about socialising in an indoors public place apply. Please see indoor socialising rules specified for each level for public/private places.

 What socialising rules apply in tourist accommodation? 

While you do not need to physically distance from family and friends in a private home or outdoors, your gathering should maintain at least 1 metre distance from all others.

In indoor public settings a distance of 1 metre distance from all other households should be maintained.

If a large room or dormitory room (e.g. within a hostel or other similar venue) is being occupied by members of a number of separate households (or extended households), whilst keeping within the 10/4 indoor socialising rule, then it should be possible for each separate household (or extended household) to maintain a physical distance of at least 1 metre from each other household (or extended household), and they are expected to do so, as a 1m physical distance is required from other households (or extended households) in all indoor public settings.  Please note that this also extends to communal rooms such as kitchens, lounges and dining rooms as well as shared bedrooms.