ASSC Submits Critical Evidence to Third Scottish Government Short-Term Lets Consultation

ASSC Submits Critical Evidence to Third Scottish Government Short-Term Lets Consultation

The Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers has submitted its response to the latest Scottish Government consultation on short-term lets.

In its comprehensive and evidence-based submission, the trade body representing the Scottish self-catering sector points to serious government failures to acknowledge the industry’s concerns over the impending licencing scheme.

If implemented, the scheme could cost a modest three-bedroom self-catering property £2,000, far in excess of the Scottish Government’s estimate.

The document points out that the heavy-handed scheme remains completely unfit for purpose even in its revised form and has been unable to convince the industry of the data supporting it.

It also highlights that only superficial changes have been made to support self-catering operators or B&Bs

The ASSC has also argued that the proposals will have a hugely detrimental impact on Scotland’s tourism sector, particularly in rural and remote areas, and form part of an ill-fitting and overreaching approach that fails to consider or address localised issues.

Self-caterers have also drawn attention to legal issues with the licensing scheme, suggesting that it is incompatible with the Provisions of Services Regulations, European Convention on Human Rights, and the Scottish Regulator’s Strategic Code of Practice on several serious points.

The licensing scheme, combined with the control area plans which may be imposed on operators in Edinburgh, would comprise the most restrictive framework in Europe which has the potential to scupper the industry’s recovery in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Rather than continuing along this path, which threatens the future of a key part of Scottish tourism, the ASSC has urged legislators to consider a mandatory programme of registration containing health and safety provisions, an approach that has near-universal industry support.

Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers Chief Executive, Fiona Campbell, said:

“The Scottish Government’s licensing proposals continue to represent a real threat to Scottish self-catering and are comprehensively and demonstratively unfit for purpose.

“Rather than this blunderbuss approach, the government should listen to our concerns and evidence-based insight, and seriously consider the industry’s mandatory registration scheme.”

“While up until now this process has been a string of disappointments and let-downs, it is not too late for the government to change its course, stay to true to its pre-election promises to the industry, and back small business for a sustainable recovery from Covid-19.”

Read the Consultation Response: ASSC Consultation Response 13.8.21

Read More:

SNP facing legal threat over plans to crackdown on Airbnbs

SNP minister: Short-term lets plans could penalise rural businesses

SNP confirms short-term lets licensing delay as opt-out plans drawn up

‘It’s a sham’: Tourism bosses quit SNP’s Airbnb crackdown group

SNP facing legal threat over plans to crackdown on Airbnbs

‘Let us be’

‘Let us be’ – tourism and business leaders hit out as they claim Scottish Government plans for licensing on self-catering and bed and breakfast short-term rentals will be disastrous for the Highland economy.

The FSB’s Highlands & Islands Development Manager, David Richardson, said,

“FSB Scotland believes that the Scottish Government’s proposed Short Term Lets legislation is the wrong legislation at entirely the wrong time.

“It is being driven by circumstances in a few hot spots like Edinburgh’s Old Town, but rather than focussing on the needs of these localities, a massive, one-size-fits-all net is now being cast over all of Scotland’s self-caterers, B&Bs and others, no matter where they are located or what the local conditions. The Scottish Government is using a massive sledgehammer to crack a nut.

“The FSB supports the appropriate regulation of short term lets, but this is not it. All minds should be focused on rebuilding struggling businesses and local economies in what we hope is the aftermath of the pandemic, and now is not the time to be introducing heavy-handed and expensive new regulations.”

Read more

Submission to STL Consultation from Scottish Land & Estates

“As an organisation representing many rural businesses with interests in a variety of short-term lets we would like to note our regret that this consultation continues to be progressed at a time when the industry is reeling from the devastating impacts of Covid-19.

“The Scottish hospitality industry in particular has been severely impacted due to the lack of visitors during the preceding 18 months. At a time when those contributing to the vital tourism industry in Scotland should be receiving further sustained support from the Scottish Government, the sector finds itself having the additional burden of attempting to unravel the possible implications of these far-reaching proposals, including the closure of reputable and long-established businesses. The proposed licensing scheme is contrary to Scottish Government public messaging that Scotland offers and provides a welcoming hospitality industry, when these measures will potentially, according to a recent survey of Association of Scottish Self Caterers (ASSC) members, see the closure of up to 49% of holiday self-catering accommodation units.”

Read the full response: Short-Term Lets Consultation Response