Accommodating Workers from Multiple Households

The ASSC has received the following guidance from the Scottish Government regarding accommodating workers from multiple households. This is very welcome news.

“We’ve carefully considered the requirements of certain sectors of the economy such as forestry, construction and digital connectivity which are reliant on shared self-catering accommodation for work purposes.  While the recommended position is for individual, self-contained accommodation for each employee, given the risks of transmission within shared accommodation, it is recognised that this is not always feasible.  Therefore, the exemption whereby workers share accommodation should only be applied where the following conditions apply:

  • Circumstances necessitate individuals to stay in shared self-catering accommodation for work purposes is defined as work which requires a physical presence in a location away from home (where the distance is such that it is not feasible to commute) and the work itself cannot be done on a virtual basis and should only be for the length of time required for work to take place and separate accommodation is unavailable or impractical.
  • Where assurance has been provided that accommodation providers and workers will comply with physical distancing and public health guidance to mitigate risk (set out below).

Special consideration should also be given to situations where a worker may be vulnerable and / or unwilling to share accommodation due to risk of Covid-19 transmission and efforts made to find suitable alternative accommodation which meets their needs.

When separate accommodation units cannot be provided and where workers are willing to share, the following guidance and mitigations should be followed:

  • Households should be limited in size to ensure that workers can access kitchens, cleaning and washing facilities and other shared spaces while maintaining physical distancing guidelines.
  • Employers and accommodation providers should conduct individual risk assessments, to ensure that there is sufficient capacity within a shared accommodation unit to ensure that users have separate bedrooms and the ability to occupy shared areas such as kitchens and toilets on their own and then clean them afterwards.  Individual risk assessment should ensure that these are of such a number that each user will have the time to occupy and use these spaces on their own and then clean them afterwards, given that at high demand times such as mornings, evenings and mealtimes such facilities will be in particular demand.
  • Workers sharing self-catering accommodation should have their own bedrooms and should adhere to physical distancing.
  • Shared bathrooms and kitchens present one of the biggest risks for increased spread of the virus.  Workers should be given the appropriate resources and instruction on how to keep shared areas clean and ventilated.
  • Residents should also be advised to use shared rooms one at a time with cleaning and ventilation in between (e.g. preparing and eating a meal).
  • Where communal toilets are available outside of households and could be used more widely, providers should implement measures to decrease this risk as far as possible in line with guidance on the reopening or public and customer toilets
  • This should include increased cleaning and may include reducing access to a one in, one out basis.  Cleaning materials should be provided for users to ‘clean as they go’.

The wording may be slightly refined within the guidance that will be published later today and we will update as required.

New Restrictions: What do they Mean?

A new five level system for Scotland will come into place on Monday 2nd November at 6am.  But practically speaking, what does this mean?  There is a great deal of confusion about the levels and they were not set in stone until Wednesday evening after the Scottish Government’s Parliamentary debate.  The current situation is explained below:

At the First Minister’s stated that the level a local authority will be placed in will be reviewed weekly.  The proposals will be put to Parliament every Tuesday and the changes will take effect every Friday.  Premises will therefore have three days warning of changes coming into effect.  The next update will be Tuesday 10th November, changes will come into effect from Friday 13th November and it will follow that pattern weekly thereafter.

Levels will be applied to a whole local authority area from 6am on Monday 2nd November, but the Scottish Government will review that and Council areas may be divided into sub areas if that is deemed necessary.

There will be no automatic application of a single statistic – the First Minister said these only inform and guide and the Scottish Government will, at first, be deliberately cautious.  The hope is to slow rate of new cases and the overall aim is to get every Council area to level 1 then level 0 of the framework.

While people should be able to meet in level 1 indoors, there is no indoor meeting allowed at present unless in a hospitality setting. This may change soon for those in level 1.

Dundee City was hoped to be in level 2 but is in level 3 due to statistics.

North and South Lanarkshire could still end up in level 4 depending on statistics which are being reviewed daily.  The decision on whether to move these Councils into level 4 will also be reviewed daily – not very helpful for hospitality venues with perishable stock and staff rotas completed who may have to close at less than 24 hours’ notice.

The First Minister stated all businesses affected can get help through the findbusinesssupport.gov.scot website.

A Christmas Loneliness strategy was also discussed. It is hoped the licensed and hospitality trades will be able to be open for Christmas and numbers able to meet indoors or in hospitality venues will be extended to facilitate family and friends meeting over the festive season and avoid loneliness and isolation.

The Scottish Government says it has expanded testing and will be taking steps to better support individuals, especially re self-isolation.  A post code checker will be introduced to help businesses and individuals identify what area they are in therefore what level they fall into at any time.  This will be particularly important if Councils are divided into sub areas as boundaries can be blurred and individuals and businesses need to be clear on what they can and cannot do.

The Council areas allocated to the various levels at present are:

  • Level 1 – Highland; Moray; Orkney; Shetland; Western Isles
  • Level 2 – Aberdeen; Aberdeenshire; Angus; Argyll & Bute; Borders; Dumfries & Galloway; Fife; Perth & Kinross
  • Level 3 – City of Glasgow; City of Edinburgh; Clackmannanshire; Dundee; East Dunbartonshire; East Lothian; East Renfrewshire; East Ayrshire; Falkirk; Inverclyde; Midlothian; North Ayrshire; North Lanarkshire; Renfrewshire; South Ayrshire; South Lanarkshire; Stirling; West Dunbartonshire; West Lothian
  • Level 4 – no Council area is in level 4 although there was discussion that North and South Lanarkshire could still end up in level 4 depending on figures.

What do the various levels allow?

  • Level 0 – Eight people from up to three households can meet indoors (with limited exceptions); fifteen people from up to five households can meet outdoors. Different rules apply to children and the Scottish Government will confirm this.  Licensing curfews will be put in place and eating and drinking may only take place seated at tables – no vertical drinking (or eating).  Takeaways are permitted for alcohol and food. Exceptions apply – hospitals, schools, student accommodation, airside premises, and hotel room service and meals for residents are excluded. Self-catering accommodation, hotels, B&Bs, self-catering, caravan and camp sites can open but restrictions above regarding socialising, hospitality rules and travel restrictions apply.  Self-catering properties are still regarded as a private home so are still subject to the restrictions re numbers able to meet indoors. Non-essential travel is not allowed from a level 0 area to a level 3 or higher areas nor to equivalent areas in the rest of UK but there are exemptions for essential travel for work, education, shopping, health, outdoor exercise, weddings and funerals, shared parenting and transit through restricted areas.  International quarantine regulations apply but otherwise travel is unrestricted.
  • Level 1 – Six people from two households can meet indoors and outdoors but not from 2nd November.  That will apply only outdoors and even level 2 areas cannot meet other families indoors except for the limited restrictions.  Hospitality would in general be open but there will be a 10.30pm curfew. Weddings and life events are restricted to a maximum of 20 people. Indoor contact sports for adults are not permitted. Only those who cannot work from home can go to their place of work.  Informal childcare is allowed
  • Level 2 – No indoor meeting is allowed, with limited exceptions.  Six people from two households can meet outdoors and in hospitality settings. Licensed premises can only serve alcohol indoors with a main meal and only until 8pm. Premises can serve food, non-alcoholic and alcoholic drinks outdoors until 10pm.  Cinemas, bingo halls and amusement arcades can open.  Gyms can open.  Other leisure and entertainment premises are closed. Informal childcare is allowed.
  • Level 3 – Cafes, pubs and restaurants can open until 6pm to serve food and non-alcoholic drinks but no sale of alcohol indoors nor outdoors.  Leisure and entertainment venues, including cinemas, will be closed. Non-essential travel is not allowed out with an area in level 3.  Indoor exercise is restricted to individuals – no dance or spin classes. Informal childcare is allowed. No indoor meeting is allowed, with limited exceptions. Accommodation, hotels, B&Bs, self-catering, caravan and camp sites can open but socialising, hospitality rules and travel restrictions apply. The Scottish Government guidance advises non-essential, leisure and tourism use is only to be by locals. Essential travel such as work-related travel can continue.

In summary, level 3 for restaurants, cafes, bars, public houses means indoors and outdoors – no alcohol; 5pm last entry; 6pm closed (a hard close – no drinking up time)

  • Level 4 – similar to lockdown restrictions in place from March to July. Schools remain open but all non-essential shops, pubs and restaurants, gyms, libraries, barbers and hairdressers are closed.  Some outdoor meeting will be allowed but that has to be clarified.

Thanks to Joanna Millar, Legal Director, Gilson Gray LLP for this briefing.

The ASSC asked the Scottish Government to consider various issues in advance of the announcements today: Strategic Framework Points for Clarification. We very much hope that these points have been considered and will be addressed in the coming days.

The Scottish Government will issue a Q&A document tomorrow, which we will distribute as soon as we can.

Read the Scottish Tourism Alliance’s response.

First Minister Statement: Covid-19 Scotland’s Strategic Framework

27th October

Background

  • The First Minister Nicola Sturgeon set out the changes to the proposed strategic framework document that was published on 23rd October and MSPs then debated the Scottish Government’s plans.
  • The Scottish Government have published a draft protection levels table[1], indicators table[2] and a letter to COSLA[3] which provide further detail of the changes.
  • The Scottish Government had engaged with opposition party leaders and business stakeholders over the preceding days.
  • This statement and debate did not outline what areas of Scotland would be subject to specific levels of restriction. That will follow this Thursday.

Main Announcements

  • The Scottish Government will take a proportionate and targeted approach to coronavirus restrictions across the country.
  • The FM stressed the flexibility of the system, confirming the detail will be kept under review.
  • The overall aim will be to get every area to Level 1 and then to Level 0 as quickly as possible.
  • A postcode checker will be launched for individuals to check which level of restrictions apply to their area.
  • On the specific levels, the FM said the following in terms of the overall approach:
  • Level 0: Similar to what Scotland experienced in August 2020
  • Level 1: Similar to what Scotland experienced in mid-September 2020
  • Level 2: Similar to current non-Central Belt restrictions
  • Level 3: Similar to current Central Belt restrictions.
  • Level 4: Similar to a full lockdown with closure of all non-essential shops. Would be a short, sharp intervention. However, six people from two households could meet outdoors. Manufacturing and construction would remain open.
  • Across all levels, the Scottish Government would expect schools and childcare to remain open.
  • The FM also provided details of how the restrictions would apply to the hospitality industry:
  • Level 0: hospitality to operate almost normally subject to rules on physical distancing, limits on numbers and table service only.
  • Level 1: similar to baseline level but with curfew closing time of 10:30pm rather than 10pm.
  • Level 2: similar to restrictions in place outside the central belt, with normal operations outdoors and an early closing time. The closing time will again be extended to 10:30pm. At present, some premises can serve food and non-alcoholic drinks indoors only until 6pm. At Level 2, this will be extended to 8pm and alcohol will be permitted with main meals.
  • Level 3: similar to current restrictions which have seen only cafes open in the central belt until 6pm to serve food and non-alcoholic drinks. But, unlike the present, pubs and restaurants will also be able to open to serve both food and non-alcoholic drinks.
  • Level 4: Hospitality closed.
  • The FM also gave an indication of what levels would apply to certain parts of Scotland but emphasised that no final decisions had been made:
  • The central belt areas currently under the tougher restrictions are likely to be in Level 3. Most of the country is likely to be in Level 2.
  • The Highlands, Orkney, Shetland, the Western Isles and Moray might go to Level 1.
  • Dundee City might go into Level 3, while North Lanarkshire and South Lanarkshire may go into Level 4.

Next Steps

  • On Thursday, prior to FMQs, the FM will set out what levels will apply to each area of Scotland
  • This will then take effect on 2 November and will be reviewed on a weekly basis.

[1] COVID-19: SCOTLAND’S STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK: LEVELS TABLE

[2] A levels approach to suppression of COVID-19-draft-25-october-2020

[3] letter-to-cosla