The Financial Impact of Short-Term Let Licensing and Planning Controls on Scottish Local Authorities

Leading tourism and business stakeholders have drawn attention to the negative impacts of the proposed short-term let regulations for the economy and tourist industry, especially in light of the pandemic, and have recommended a postponement. However, the costs to local councils of implementing short-term let licensing and planning control areas also needs to be properly considered. This has been made more difficult in the absence of a Business Regulatory Impact Assessment on the proposals.

  • Legal and planning stakeholders have highlighted the challenges that the Scottish Government plans will place on local authorities, many of whom did not support the proposals in the consultation process, and the financial impact this will have on already stretched resources.
  • In recent weeks, discussions have taken place at City of Edinburgh Council meetings where councillors have sought more detail on the resource implications arising from the Scottish Government’s plans.
  • The Financial Memorandum for the Planning (Scotland) Bill estimated that the cost to planning authorities of additional applications resulting from short-term lets would be between £358,207 and £2.7m per year. Given that this was prepared in 2017, the costs may have increased further. In addition, this estimation only deals with one aspect of the regulatory framework, planning, and did not consider the costs of licensing.
  • Research carried out by the RTPI in connection with the implementation of the Planning (Scotland) Act 2019 estimated the costs of a planning authority designating all or part of its area as a short-term let control area between £640,710 (lower estimate) and £14,756,800 (higher estimate).[1] It does not appear that additional funds will be available for planning authorities to carry out the necessary work.
  • Legal experts have predicted a surge in licensing applications for short-term lets for when the scheme goes live, potentially overwhelming local authority departments. Stephen McGowan, head of Licensing (Scotland) at TLT LLP and an authority on the 1982 Civic Government Act on which the Scottish Government’s plans are based, said the following:

“Provision will need to be made to deal with the impact of such a magnitude of applications on local authority resources. A massive rush of applications of this order could bring licensing administration to a halt, and have a knock-on effect on reporting obligations with Police Scotland and other authorities such as Fire and Building Standards, who will likely have to comment on each application. This could impact on processing times for other types of civic licence.”[2]

  • This was echoed by the legal firm Shepherd and Wedderburn:

“In addition to any increased workload for licensing departments, there will likely be an impact on the Police, Fire Service, Building Standards and others who may be required to comment on applications. It will therefore be vital that the Scottish Government ensures the necessary resources are in place together with sufficient publicity to facilitate a smooth transition to the new licensed regime.”[3]

  • Similarly, the Law Society of Scotland said:

“We query what opportunities have been considered for sharing services (e.g. with those involved with inspection processes related to Fire and Rescue Services) as some of the inspection processes should replicate ones that exist already. This could involve dedicated teams or an in housing/HMO team. Unresolved issues regarding fee setting is only one part of the resource implications. The numbers of staff involved is the more crucial factor as this licensing regime is imposing on local authorities additional requirement for staff. The number of applications and the need for this process could impact other areas of work such as e.g. liquor, street traders, public entertainment, and taxi licences. This licensing scheme is introducing additional requirements when authorities are already hard-pressed. In certain areas there will be a flood of applications which will require immediate short-term staffing issues, the implications of which should be considered now.”

  • Stephen McGowan of TLT LLP also noted the following on the implications of licensing and provided a comparison with changes made to the liquor licensing regime:

“It has been put to me that councils can “gear up” and bring in temporary staff to help process these applications, but that would only take us so far. There are approximately 32,000 properties in Scotland registered on the successful Airbnb platform alone. By contrast, when the liquor licensing regime changed in 2009 there were around 16,500 applications to process and it was a mammoth task for everyone concerned. The licensing system is supposed to wash its own face and it will be for local authorities to determine a fee for these applications to cover projected costs, but even that is not the full picture.

Licensing is a specialist area and the impact of the new regime is not just about the cost of employing temporary office staff to process bits of paper. It’s also about the inspections that will have to occur in order to produce reports that the properties meet the required safety standards.

There is also the impact on police resource. Every application will need to be reported on and every person checked for criminal convictions and so on. The police may also be asked to report on evidence of antisocial behaviour. The police will see no percentage of the licence fee, and all of this will be happening on top of the other licensing business that both the council and the police are dealing with. It is not too wild a projection to see how the licensing system itself could creak and create delay and logjam, without the right precautions being taken.”[4]

  • The Royal Town Planning Institute (RTPI) raised a number of concerns with the proposals for local councils, highlighting the following points:
  • “major concerns about the resource implications of changes to the regulatory framework
  • the related impacts associated with the additional duties for local councils set out within the Planning (Scotland) Act 2019 which remain uncosted
  • the overall financial context of diminishing resources in Councils, both staff levels and fee income streams
  • the need for effective enforcement measures and joint working across several Council services
  • a clear and simple set of procedures with limited data requirements.”[5]
  • The Law Society of Scotland also warned on the cost of the regulations and that local authorities may not be ready from a resourcing perspective: “There are unlikely to be resources in place at present in local authority licensing or planning departments to cover such additional and in certain areas, extensive work.”[6] The policy intention is that the fee levels should cover adequately the staff and administrative costs. However, that ignores the considerable cost of establishing the scheme:

“There are often significant infrastructure costs in introducing new schemes, for example new IT systems, which cannot always be fully recovered…We question whether it is proportionate for applicants to be fully liable for costs of establishing a system, including preparing staff to run the scheme. We suggest that it is appropriate to consider this question in the context of balancing the extent of the mischief which the scheme aims to regulate with the potential gain to the wider public of regulation.”

“In addition, there are likely to be practical challenges with this approach. How may each local authority calculate expected numbers of applications be quantified to be able to work out what the costs should be per application? What is the approach to be by local authorities to differing circumstances, for example, those undertaking home sharing versus those undertaking secondary letting? The omission of a BRIA, or partial BRIA, from this consultation make these questions particularly pertinent.”[7]

  • The Licensing Law Committee of the Law Society of Scotland emphasised the importance of piloting the new licensing scheme ahead of implementing the new powers – but the Scottish Government have no plans to do this.
  • It is clear that increased regulation will place additional burdens on local authority planning and licensing teams to manage the requirements of a new scheme at a time when they can least afford it. A proper impact assessment of the costs is required and it underlines the case that a postponement of the regulations is desirable.

4th December 2020

[1] https://www.rtpi.org.uk/media/1211/rtpi-scotland-financial-implications-of-implementing-the-planning-scotland-act-2019.pdf

[2] https://www.scottishlegal.com/article/licensing-expert-warns-of-flood-of-short-term-let-licences-1

[3] https://shepwedd.com/knowledge/short-term-letting-greater-regulation-licensing-and-control-scotland-post-covid-19-world

[4] https://www.lawscot.org.uk/members/journal/issues/vol-65-issue-02/system-overload-licensing-short-term-lets/

[5] https://www.rtpi.org.uk/consultations/2020/october/short-term-lets/

[6] https://www.lawscot.org.uk/media/363183/19-07-19-plan-lic-short-term-lets.pdf

[7] https://www.lawscot.org.uk/media/369667/20-10-16-plan-lic-consultation-short-term-lets-regulations.pdf

Covid-19 Guidance – Updates 4th December

We have had the following guidance from the Scottish Government this afternoon:

Click on the Link Below to view details.

Key points:

  • Outwith the festive period (23-27 December inclusive), it is illegal to travel for non-essential purposes from the rest of the UK to Scotland.
  • Travel between Scotland, England, Wales and Northern Ireland is permitted to allow families and friends to gather to form a Christmas bubble between 23 to 27 December (22 to 28 December for entering and leaving Northern Ireland).
  • The location of a Christmas bubble in Scotland must be in the local authority area which a member of the bubble has their main residence.
  • A bubble can meet in self-catered accommodation for a Christmas gathering, but only in the local authority area in which you or a member of your bubble lives.
  • Operators should check that at least one household participating is from within the postcode area.
  • Guests can only travel in line with festive guidance for bubbles but not for leisure.  If they are not gathering with another household, the holiday relaxations do not apply to them.
  • People should comply with the rules applicable to their local authority area in Scotland. Please note the levels and the contents of the levels is reviewed on a regular basis.
  • Hogmanay does not fall within the agreed Four Nation festive period.
  • In level 0, 1 or 2 you can move between levels in either 0, 1 or 2 but are advised to minimise rather than avoid these journeys to minimise any potential virus spread.
  • This is Law – legal provisions are through the Health Protection (Coronavirus) (Restrictions and Requirements (Local Levels) (Scotland) Amendment (No. 3.) Regulations 2020.

Tourism – Covid-19 – Self-catering Guidance – 2 December 2020 (008)

VisitScotland have also compiled a list of the top 10 Frequently Asked Questions from what hospitality businesses can and can’t do in respect of bookings to what’s happening over the Christmas period to travelling between Levels. Read more here.

Financial Support

Oliver Mundell (Dumfriesshire) (Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party) tabled the following Parliamentary Question this week:

To ask the Scottish Government whether self-catering premises in local authority areas subject to Level (a) 1, (b) 2 and (c) 3 restrictions, whose businesses are directly affected by the impact of travel restrictions, are eligible to receive a COVID-19 business restrictions grant.(S5W-33530)

Fergus Ewing: The Strategic Framework Business Fund offers financial support to businesses legally required to close or to modify their operations. Self-catering businesses in Levels 1&2 or 3, affected by travel restrictions are not eligible for this support. Self-catering businesses required to close in level 4 may be eligible for support if they meet the eligibility criteria. Coronavirus Business Support Grants, the Tourism Hardship fund, rates relief and the £1.5 million Coronavirus Support scheme have all supported self-caterers. We have also provided an additional £30m to support businesses through the local authority discretionary fund. Scotland’s lack of borrowing powers prevents us from fully responding to the economic crisis, and limited funds mean that we must target resources.

 

Press Release: Scottish Tourism Condemns Scottish Government “Bubbles” Fiasco

The Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers (ASSC), Scotland’s trade body representing the self-catering sector, has joined with other industry leaders to condemn the Scottish Government for failing to work with Scottish tourism on new COVID-19 restrictions.

Representatives from the Scottish Tourism Alliance, the Professional Association of Self-Caterers UK, Scottish AgriTourism, Visit Inverness Loch Ness, Visit Moray Speyside, Visit Arran, South of Scotland Destination Alliance and the Wales Tourism Alliance amongst others have come together behind the strong criticisms of the recently published rules.

The last-minute changes will have a severe and negative impact on the sector which has already been unfairly burdened by government measures, despite cooperating fully with government throughout the pandemic.

Ministers have decided that Scots can get together in so-called “festive bubbles” when restrictions are relaxed temporarily between 23 December and 27 December.

However, the decision was made without proper consultation with, or consideration for, Scotland’s already hamstrung £723million traditional self-catering sector, a decision the ASSC strongly condemns.

Of particular concern to self-caterers is the extremely limiting measure that will mean that someone from any given “bubble” intending to stay in self-catering accommodation will need to live in the local authority that the self-catering property is located in.

The ASSC has also slammed the government for failing to communicate adequately with the industry.

Worse still, the new limitations place an unfair burden on Scotland’s hard-working self-caterers who will have to enforce the rules themselves as it has been left to them to establish that visitors to their properties are members of the same bubble and that at least one household participating is from within the local council area.

The ASSC also condemned the fact that the poorly considered proposals deviate from the four nations approach and as such has caused confusion and worry for operators both in Scotland and across the United Kingdom.

Members of the ASSC were among the first to respond to calls to limit the spread of the virus by shutting down their properties, at great personal and professional cost, and have also led the way to economic recovery by reopening early with government-backed cleaning protocols in place.

The contribution the sector has made to the effort against COVID-19 has made it even more disappointing that the Scottish Government has made such a short-sighted, ill-considered, and ambiguous decision that will impact many Scottish small business owners in a negative way.

ASSC Chief Executive, Fiona Campbell, said:

“It is frankly devastating that the Scottish Government has acted in such a thoughtless manner towards our sector – they’ve created nothing short of a fiasco in our industry.

“Our sector has worked tirelessly, and endured so much strife, as part of the effort against COVID-19 so to be forgotten in this way feels like a stab in the back from a government that we thought we had a good relationship with.

“We can only hope that ministers listen to our concerns, and those of our valued colleagues across Scottish tourism, before all we have are a collection of empty properties, broken businesses, and shattered dreams.”

Marc Crothall, CEO of the Scottish Tourism Alliance, said:

“I have raised the issue of communication with government officials on the weekly STERG call today and again stressed the importance of industry having clearer and more timely communications re guidance both to avoid confusion for business and our visitors looking to book.

When every penny counts and people are stretched  the need to make all coms clear to all from the outset is essential so business and visitors know what they can and cannot do and effective planning and forecasting can be done.

“It is difficult enough right now for all business’ to manage through this pandemic, whilst the industry appreciates that there continues to be lots of moving parts and everyone is stretched it’s all the more reason for the need for utmost clarity in all communications.

“This will avoid what has in the past caused much uncertainty, lots of upset, avoidable administration, and significant loss of business for some.”

ENDS